Well put, GG, and I agree.
Even though I would list Ella at the top for me, I really have FOUR favorite jazz vocalists of "all time." Two men and two women:
Ella Fitzgerald
Sarah Vaughan
Mel Torme
Frank Sinatra
I was lucky enough to have seen three of the four live:
Ella - in Kansas City on a double bill with Count Basie. He was too sick to perform that night, so Ella agreed to do an extra set... and ended up singing for over 2 1/2 hours with only one 10-minute break. She ran out of material halfway through her last set, and asked the audience (a very large audience) what they wanted to hear. She would turn around and discuss it with her trio for a few seconds, and then launch into the song. It was like having your own "live" Ella jukebox. Incredible!
Sarah - I saw her twice. Once at the Blue Note in NY. The most amazing club performance I've ever seen/heard. She was not a "showy" performer. She was the ultimate singer however. And I will never forget it. I also saw her a few years later at the Hollywood Bowl with the L.A. Phil. doing her Gershwin Live material. Not as good, because she had trouble hearing the large orchestra behind her, and she got pissed! Fascinating, nonetheless. She was gone, less than a year later.
Frank - In Kansas City. It was right after "New York, New York" was a surprise hit song and ended up on the Billboard Pop Charts. So, in addition to being "Frank" he was also the "new hot thing." As if he needed that boost to sell tickets. He did two sets with a full big band, which were both great. But he did a third set with just a guitar. That's when I was completely blown away by his musicianship and his talent. Take away the frills and the slick production... and just give me that voice with a guitar... and you have pure magic. And a connection with an audience like no other. Another night I'll never forget.
I have a few contemporary favorites: Ann Hampton Calloway is probably at the top of that list. Others are hit and miss for me. But so few are able to get to the heart of the music, and instead cover it up with slick style and "smoke and mirrors." I can only take so much of that before I need to hear a PERSON behind all of that. Often, you peel away the fancy stylistic layers, and there's nothing left inside. Nothing human to back it up.
That's why I prefer the singers of yesteryear.
You can definitely add Billie Holliday to the list for me... but sometimes her world-weary sound is a bit over-the-top, either due to the "too much style" scenario... or (most likely) the "too much drugs" scenario. And I think I'm guilty of hearing WAY too many imitators of her voice. There are still so many today in Pop music that try to sound like they just fell out of rehab, or just woke up. As if that substituted for "acting" a song, or developing a personality of their own. At least it comes off that way to me more often than not. Billie was an original. And too many people seem to want to be that, via her.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22