I'll start:
Matthew Morrison = Paul Ryan
John Mahoney = Ron Paul
Now your turn...
Broadway Star Joined: 6/26/11
Ian McKellen as Ron Paul
Warren Beatty as Mitt Romney
Ryan Reynolds as Rick Santorum (or at least I see it anyways)
Amanda Bynes as Michelle Bachman (they both got crazy eyes)
Louis Gossett jr. as Herman Caine (Morgan Freeman is too easy)
I'd go with your choice for Matthew Morrison as Paul Ryan
Who could play Joe Biden,Newt Gingrich, and most important, Marcus Bachman?
Eric Stonestreet is clearly Marcus Bachmann.
I completely forgot Herman Caine existed.
This is the one that I think will be fun to cast. Joanna Lumley perhaps? (or Conan O'Brien)
Actually, Joanna would make a great Ann Romney
Christine Baranski?
Steve Carrell must play Rick Santorum
I don't actually want there to be a 2012 election to even base a movie on. For some reason my anxiety this go around is ten times worse.
Broadway Legend Joined: 2/20/04
Harry Lennix Jr. as the President.
Richard Schiff as David Axelrod (since he was essenmially playing him on the West Wing.)
Tyra Banks as The First lady.
Videos