Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Disney's SONG OF THE SOUTH In Talks For DVD Release...Again — Page 3

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#51

re: Disney's SONG OF THE SOUTH In Talks For DVD Release...Again

I'm with Auggie--I don't like censorship of any kind. I saw SOTS in the theatre when I was a kid and saw many of the other banned cartoons on the rotten.com site. I didn't turn out to be a skinhead--in fact, just the opposite.

And if that horrid performance by Mickey Rooney in Breakfast at Tiffany's can get through, anything should.
#52

re: Disney's SONG OF THE SOUTH In Talks For DVD Release...Again

I own copies of most of Disney's animated films - including a VHS of 'Song of the South'. This movie has some amazing animation sequences, memorable songs, and does a credible job of telling folk stories in the context presented. I do understand that some people feel uncomfortable with the film's subject matter and the jargon used in the film to present it. Hence, Disney has had this film locked down tight for years. I would support release of this movie in DVD format and let the public judge the film on its merits and shortcomings. However, I highly doubt that Disney will release SOTS on DVD, even with a PC introduction and suggestion to view this film through a 'historical perspective' lens.
#53

re: Disney's SONG OF THE SOUTH In Talks For DVD Release...Again

I own a video copy of Song of the South and really hope they release it on DVD. I really think that the PC police have been working overtime on this movie.

The movie shows a white boy whose parents are split up (possibly going through a divorce). His mother is too preoccupied to comfort him. He goes in search of someone, and finds Uncle Remus, a wise man who tells interesting stories. The movie also shows the boy's friendships with a black boy and a poor white girl. The point that children get out of this is that friendship doesn't have color or economic taboos.


If anyone ever tells you that you put too much Parmesan cheese on your pasta, stop talking to them. You don't need that kind of negativity in your life.
#54

re: Disney's SONG OF THE SOUTH In Talks For DVD Release...Again

re: Disney's SONG OF THE SOUTH In Talks For DVD Release...Again

Just additional information regrading Disney and minorities:

http://www.thememoryhole.org/arts/sunflower.htm

"In 1940, Disney released Fantasia, which has become one of the all-time classics of animation. The groundbreaking film is made up of several vignettes, each set to a classical composition performed by the Philadelphia Orchestra and its conductor, Leopold Stokowski."

"The segment of the film set to Beethoven's "Pastoral Symphony" contained three shots with a black female centaur (named Sunflower). Performing menial duties for the blonde, white female centaurs, Sunflower is a racial stereotype along the lines of Amos and Andy, Buckwheat, and Aunt Jemima."

"Starting with the 1960 theatrical re-release, Sunflower was cut from the movie. In all of the various releases of Fantasia on videocassette, laser disc, and DVD, she has remained missing. At first, her scenes were simply cut. In later versions, her scenes are in the movie, but the shots have been cropped so that she is no longer on-screen."

"According to the Internet Movie Database, the Disney company has denied that such a character was ever in Fantasia. Fortunately, at least one screen shot survives (above). I believe the source for this image is the book Cartoon Confidential by Jim Korkis and John Cawley (Malibu Graphics Press, 1991)."

FYI...There's also an short clip at a certain website.

#55

re: Disney's SONG OF THE SOUTH In Talks For DVD Release...Again

re: Disney's SONG OF THE SOUTH In Talks For DVD Release...Again

Last month, Disney released an uncut version of the 1938 Silly Symphony MOTHER GOOSE GOES HOLLYWOOD as part of a 'Disney Treasures - More Silly Symphonies' DVD. Featuring animated caricatures of The Marx Brothers, Freddie Bartholomew, Charles Laughton, Garbo, Edward G. Robinson, Fred Astaire, Spencer Tracy, Martha Raye, Joe E. Brown and (most notably) Katherine Hepburn as Little Bo-Peep, it's not quite as funny as you'd want it to be (the funniest bit for me is Mother Goose roaring as Leo the Lion, over a banner reading "Nuts to You" in pig Latin, which reportedly infuriated Louis B. Mayer), but it features caricatures of Cab Calloway and his Orchestra, Fats Waller and Stepin Fetchit all with huge pink lips (as "Four and Twenty Blackbirds Baked in A Pie" - though the most outrageous moment is when Oliver Hardy throws a pie at Stan Laurel - only to hit Hepburn in the kisser - as the pie drips down, she is in blackface and drawls "Have any of y'all seen mah sheep?"



Mother Goose Goes Hollywood - Frame Blow-ups


"Christ, Bette Davis?!?!"

Updated On: 1/19/07 at 01:40 PM

#57

re: Disney's SONG OF THE SOUTH In Talks For DVD Release...Again

WindyCityActor---Fascinating! Thanks for sharing that.

I've always known about this cut in Fantasia, but I've never seen a picture of the "deleted racism."

The IMDb is a little behind on the denial. It WAS mentioned (although EXTREMELY downplayed, when Fantasia was released on DVD). They aren't denying it these days, but they are doing all they can to forget it was ever in the movie.

I'm glad Disney doesn't lie about these things any longer, but they sure used to. It only comes back to haunt them. Somebody always finds a discarded copy somewhere that exposes the truth. And then they're branded as liars, as well as racists. Not exactly a winning situation. Better settle for one, over both.

Lately they've been taking a lot of hits for their "inebriation" scenes, one in Fantasia (same as this, with Bacchus celebrating the drinking of wine), and one in Dumbo with his Pink Elephants delirium. Both played for laughs, in an "ain't that cute? He's drunk!" sort of way. Not so very PC though in a family film.

But at this rate, I'm guessing all Disney's animated features pre 1989 will evenutally be 30 minutes long.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22
#58

re: Disney's SONG OF THE SOUTH In Talks For DVD Release...Again

Not Disney related, but I was also pissed that Spielberg digitally changed the feds' guns to walkie-talkies for the 2002 reissue of E.T. Lame!
Salve, Regina, Mater misericordiae
Vita, dulcedo, et spes nostra
Salve, Salve Regina
Ad te clamamus exsules filii Eva
Ad te suspiramus, gementes et flentes
O clemens O pia
#59

re: Disney's SONG OF THE SOUTH In Talks For DVD Release...Again

Hmmm.. the more I think about it, I coming to the conclusion that Disney should release the film... ONLY if they release it as it was originally seen in theatres.. all scenes intact without any chages to the images or audio.

and..

If they mass market it to children like they do their other films with tie-ins to fast food resturants, clothing lines and other such products.

The image of middle class white parents giving their children copies of SONG OF THE SOUTH on christmas day would be priceless.

I could be shown in Elementary Schools too. That would be a hoot.

We could start the ball rolling on creating a new generation of Euro-American children who understand what it was like in the good old days; and with "wink" letting them know that with a little hard work we can have like that again.

....

What I'm really perplexed about is why there are so many presumably white people so eager to have this film sitting on their shelves and to share it with the children in their lives.

I understand wanting to see it for historical reasons...even aesthetic reasons.. but the ferocious NEED to have it at available at every retail store, boggles me.

The film IS available. It can be ordered on line.. possible supporing white supremists groups.. but that can't be an issue if you REALLY have a need to own the film.

Anyone who wants it can get it. Why you need to have it in a glossy package available at the check stand is beyond. Is your addiciton to a hit of Disney "magic" to intense that you would risk having a new generation of black children made to fell inferior and a new generation white children feel superior?














Walk on, walk on, with hope in your heart; and you'll never walk alone.

Updated On: 1/19/07 at 02:32 PM

#60

re: Disney's SONG OF THE SOUTH In Talks For DVD Release...Again

WalkOn---I never got that impression when I saw the film unedited, first in the theatre and then later on VHS.

It didn't turn me into a racist after watching it, anymore than Brokeback Mountain turned me gay.

Also, these weren't "good ol' days" portrayed in the movie. The father goes off to war and everyone is worried that they might not see him again. They try to keep all of this hidden from his young son, so instead he feels abandoned by his father, and looks to Uncle Remus to fill the void, give him hope, and guide him.

Yes, it's full of stereotypes... But that doesn't sound like anybody's "good ol' days," white or black.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22
#61

re: Disney's SONG OF THE SOUTH In Talks For DVD Release...Again

The "good old days" that I refer to have to with the economic status and relative leisure of the white family. This level of comfortable living has all to do with enslavement and servitude of africans.

Yes, the family had problems to deal with, but from the prespective of those had to serve them... the masters problems where relatively minor. How could a slave/servant care about the dissoultion of a marriage when they had probably seen their own children taken away and sold. How could they care if the Master returned or not from fighting a war to keep them enslaved?

I saw it it 1986, when I was teenager. I believe it had been edited. Still, I found it disturbing and and almost painful. I am not african american, but I am not Euro-American either. My feelings were at odds: the animation was beautiful, the music delightful.. and little boy charming.. but the mythical south of happy servants was a constant reminder that those around me would rather hold that image in their conscious than live with the heavy pain of the truth... and because it hadn't happend to their race they had the option.

Added to that - and this I understand might be offensive, but the film reinforces to me the the idea that Euro-Americans actually LIKE to indulge in the fantasy of being attended to and waited upon those they have decided are inferior. At the very least the fantasy doesn't seem to offend them.

Again I have to question the motivation of anyone who is has such a burning NEED to have this film shown to all the children in the US.










Walk on, walk on, with hope in your heart; and you'll never walk alone.

Updated On: 1/19/07 at 03:05 PM

#62

re: Disney's SONG OF THE SOUTH In Talks For DVD Release...Again

What makes SONG OF THE SOUTH difficult for me to sit through is the upchuck-inducing, syrupy sentimentality of the scenes with the white child actors Bobby Discoll and Luana Patten, whose thespian abilities make one appreciate the brilliance of Shirley Temple and Margaret O'Brien.

"Christ, Bette Davis?!?!"

Updated On: 1/19/07 at 03:42 PM

#63

re: Disney's SONG OF THE SOUTH In Talks For DVD Release...Again

WalkOn, I don't think the argument is so much whether any of us have a burning need to see it -- I certainly don't, as it didn't make much of a favorable impression on me when I saw it in a theater as a child -- but whether it should be held out of distribution when there are already equally offensive things (the Dumbo crows, as has already been mentioned) on the market already.

Updated On: 1/19/07 at 03:46 PM

#64

re: Disney's SONG OF THE SOUTH In Talks For DVD Release...Again

With all due respect, and I mean that sincerely, Calvin. It ISN'T out of distribution. It is readily available. It can be purchased from markets overseas.

This is not an issue of censorship. Disney owns it and can do whatever it wants it with it. It is an artists choice to have his/her works shown or not shown.

Walk on, walk on, with hope in your heart; and you'll never walk alone.

Updated On: 1/19/07 at 03:50 PM

#65

re: Disney's SONG OF THE SOUTH In Talks For DVD Release...Again

Craig, of COURSE it's not out because of the politics. That's a given. You think they would NOT release it just for the hell of it? It's an unmined diamond mine they're sitting on.

best12bars, that's also given that they're a corporation. I'm just stating it's sad that the Corp will use the controversy as a gimmick to get quick dough. It can't be helped, though.
"The Spectacle has, indeed, an emotional attraction of its own, but, of all the parts, it is the least artistic, and connected least with the art of poetry. For the power of Tragedy, we may be sure, is felt even apart from representation and actors. Besides, the production of spectacular effects depends more on the art of the stage machinist than on that of the poet."
--Aristotle
#66

re: Disney's SONG OF THE SOUTH In Talks For DVD Release...Again

WalkOn & Capn---I'm going to guess Disney ISN'T going to try to ram this one down kid's throats. That would only add to any issues that would be raised.

If they do actually end up releasing it, look for it to be marketed along the lines of their "Lost Treasures" series, or their "Vault Disney" titles. Or the recent nature films.

Clearly spinning it as a relic of the past, a bit of nostalgia, not "here's something new for the kiddies."
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22
#67

re: Disney's SONG OF THE SOUTH In Talks For DVD Release...Again

I remember Mother Goose goes Hollywood. They were still showing it on the Disney Channel uncut when I was a child in the early 80's. I still say half of my early knowledge of classic hollywood came from these and warner brothers spoofs on Hollywood of the 30's and 40's.

I wish Song of the South would get a dvd release but that Disney would do it quietly and not market it as a children's film but a comment on another time. Get notable african american directors/actors to do a commentary track or interviews on the film and racisim in Hollywood at the time. If Disney showed and admitted that it was a misstep and a misguided film. I don't know, maybe what I'm saying is just as wrong. I do collect these bits of nostalga cartoons though. The racism is shocking and its also an interesting comment on the past. All the way from the propoganda cartoons from WW2 to the Little Sambo/Jungle Savage WB Cartoons to the uncut Our Gang and Amos and Andy shorts. I hope this sees the light of day.
I got rid of my teeth at a young age because... I'm straight. Teeth are for gay people. That's why fairies come and get them
#68

re: Disney's SONG OF THE SOUTH In Talks For DVD Release...Again

Umm sidenote. I know everyone gets offended by the gross charactures of the the african americans in these cartoons. But the gross characture of Italian actors is just as bad. Are we allowed to be angry about that too?
I got rid of my teeth at a young age because... I'm straight. Teeth are for gay people. That's why fairies come and get them
#69

re: Disney's SONG OF THE SOUTH In Talks For DVD Release...Again

now i have the urge to sing the theme from 2000 MANIACS

"robert e lee
broke his musket on his knee
& a thousand pieces
fell upon the ground
YEEEEEEEEEEE-HAW!!!
the souths gonna rise again!!!"
#70

re: Disney's SONG OF THE SOUTH In Talks For DVD Release...Again

regarding the plot: father and mother have separated. mother and boy go to live with grandmother on the "plantation" while father stays in atlanta. boy tries to run away, but one of uncle rhemus' stories convinces him not to.
RIP glebby <3
#74

re: Disney's SONG OF THE SOUTH In Talks For DVD Release...Again

"regarding the plot: father and mother have separated. mother and boy go to live with grandmother on the "plantation" while father stays in atlanta. boy tries to run away, but one of uncle rhemus' stories convinces him not to."

Yes, cturtle, that's exactly the way I remember it. But his parents haven't separated due to "marital differences" (surely not in a Disney movie in 1940, set in the 1860s!)... the dad is going to fight in the war. He takes his wife and young son down to the grandmother's plantation while he goes off to battle. Everyone is worried whether or not they will see him again. And the boy doesn't understand this, and just thinks his father is abandoning them.

Right?

EDIT: I admit it's been a while since I saw it. Maybe it's really set in Japan, and the father is going off to be Shogun. I can't remember.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22

Updated On: 1/21/07 at 10:27 AM

#75

re: Disney's SONG OF THE SOUTH In Talks For DVD Release...Again

b12b: The story takes place not long after the Civil War (hence no more slavery) and Johnny's parents do separate due to "marital differences," as you put it. Johnny and his mother go stay at a grandmother's plantation, while his father returns to Atlanta to work as a newspaper editor. His father only comes back after Johnny gets attacked by a bull, and his parents inevitably make up. That's pretty much the story in a nutshell.
Salve, Regina, Mater misericordiae
Vita, dulcedo, et spes nostra
Salve, Salve Regina
Ad te clamamus exsules filii Eva
Ad te suspiramus, gementes et flentes
O clemens O pia

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $60
Hot Show
Tickets From $71