I got mentioned! WooHoo!
Yes, that was a great conversation, the gist of which is that we still never saw an unbiased view of the mature James Potter, he almost certainly grew and changed although I think his flaws are an essential part of the story- he never could have been what Lily (and Harry) was.
I really think all the characters are essential to the story and their struggles and flaws make them even better.
My personal favorites (some I love, others I love to hate)
The Trio (together, with all their flaws and irritations)
Severus Snape
Albus Dumbledore
Tonks
Remus Lupin
Sirius Black
Ginny
Delores Umbridge
Minerva McGonagall
Luna and Neville
I realize this list could keep on going forever, I have a reason to love just about ever character in the books.
The ones I am not as fond of
Crabbe and Goyle (They are just a bit too cartoonish and underdeveloped)
I stand corrected, you are as vapid as they say.