I just got back from the movie. I am a HUGE HUGE HUGE Lost fan. I listen to podcasts, discuss each episode at length, read about it on the net etc. etc.
All I can say is I hope JJ had nothing to do with Cloverfield other than provide money. I really thought that it was one of the worst films I've seen in a long time. I didn't read through the whole thread, so maybe I'm repeating what others have said, but I walked out of there saying "what was the point?" The movie was nothing more than if they handed someone in the city a camera when King Kong attacked. Only then, we would know something about the monster that's attacking.
This is the fatal flaw of the movie: we don't know enough to give a damn, and there's not enough given anywhere along the way to have made this any different from any other monster movie.
I didn't care about the people at all (I kept thinking they're a device to try to reel us in - it felt so phony), and there was nothing in the movie that we haven't seen over and over again in other monster movies.
Had the film given us SOMETHING of a twist, some explanation at the end, something NEW, I would have forgiven the rest of the movie. As it was, I knew no more about the movie after watching it than I did going in: monster attacks city, guy records from his perspective. And that's it!
The only really redeeming part for me were the clips of Coney Island - I mean, the attempt at making a connection for the characters was a bit TOO contrived from a story telling vantage, but the idea of the camera cutting to what was being taped over was pretty cool.
All in all, VERY disappointed, and there will be LEGIONS of pissed off people if Lost doesn't end WAY better than this! I give it a D-
Hi, Shirley Temple Pudding.