Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Rosie on WTC 7 and O'Reilly et al's Response

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#1

Rosie on WTC 7 and O'Reilly et al's Response

I *know* that another thread mentions this, however, that thread has turned into a back-and-forth about who HDThoreau is (eg "threadjacked").

I want to return to the REAL issue that REALLY MATTERS. The rest of this post will not be my words. Here is a blog entry by a friend of mine who is neutral to Rosie and I don't think has ever watched THE VIEW until I told him about Rosie's WTC 7 statement she made last week. Here is his post:

"To anyone who reads this i desperately plea that you take it seriously and do not brush it off.

For a long time now I have been an advocate for the 9/11 Truth Movement.

Recently this movement, despite how fringe the mainstream media thinks it is, has been getting national attention thanks to people like Charlie Sheen, who has been signed on to be the narrator of an upcoming 9/11 truth documentary, Loose Change: Final Cut. He has been criticized and ridiculed by cable news programs such as the o reilly factor and scarbarough country.

But even more stunning than that, is how the media is reacting to Rosie O Donnell publically speaking about the facts of the matter on the show the View.

Take a look http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MiIyI6ugmUM

She plainly says that it is impossible for a building to collapse, a STEEL BUILDING, because of fire. She does not go into the twin towers, she merely mentions World Trade Center 7. The official explanation of its collapse was fire that fell from the twin towers that caused structural damage and made it collapse perfectly to the ground. Rosie points out that this is an impossibility. Now, look at how the media is reacting to her statements.

Hannity and Colmes: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kue3WITRL1g

notice anything strange about the coverage of rosies comments?

O Reilly and Geraldo: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cYxTG1ITsUU&mode=related&search=

see a pattern here?

These mainstream cable news channel people are simply calling Rosie crazy for her views. Do you ever ONCE here them actually talk about what Rosie was saying and debate whether or not its true, or how it cant be true? No. These people have no other choice but to denounce the statements that they cant argue with by demonizing who is saying them.

People...please. Do not listen to these mainstream assholes and take everything they say as the gospel. Do some research. Look at the facts. Make your own conclusions. I, like everybody else, believed everything the news told me after 9/11. But the fact of the matter is, what happened on that day, how, why, and who are still questions that should be up for debate and discussion in this country. They should be talked about, and not spat on or dismissed.

I urge you all to go to www.911truth.com and get ready, because this is not a dying movement. This is not a silenced movement. Recent polls show that 30% of americans believe the government had knowledge of the attacks before they happened, and even more believe that we are not being told the full truth. The investigation is not over. If we are at war because of a misconception, because of a lie, or a twist in the truth...i cant even imagine how incredibly evil that is.

Bush himself said the constitution was just a piece of paper. He is wiping his ass with it, and our rights as americans are being taken away. Lets not let this happen. We cant let this happen.

Get ready because Loose Change: The Final Cut will be released in theatres across the world, and they will have no choice but to openly talk about its message. Get ready."
"The Spectacle has, indeed, an emotional attraction of its own, but, of all the parts, it is the least artistic, and connected least with the art of poetry. For the power of Tragedy, we may be sure, is felt even apart from representation and actors. Besides, the production of spectacular effects depends more on the art of the stage machinist than on that of the poet."
--Aristotle
#2

re: Rosie on WTC 7 and O'Reilly et al's Response

Bump.
"The Spectacle has, indeed, an emotional attraction of its own, but, of all the parts, it is the least artistic, and connected least with the art of poetry. For the power of Tragedy, we may be sure, is felt even apart from representation and actors. Besides, the production of spectacular effects depends more on the art of the stage machinist than on that of the poet."
--Aristotle
#4

re: Rosie on WTC 7 and O'Reilly et al's Response

Thanks for the link, PJ! It's an interesting counter-read. I scanned through some of the comments that blog entry received. People are so split. Some can't stand Rosie and just think she is spreading her agenda. Others look into it more and make comments like "Look who owns Popular Mechanics. I don't trust Rosie and I don't trust Corporate America" or "and other photos you exclude help prove against your claim."
"The Spectacle has, indeed, an emotional attraction of its own, but, of all the parts, it is the least artistic, and connected least with the art of poetry. For the power of Tragedy, we may be sure, is felt even apart from representation and actors. Besides, the production of spectacular effects depends more on the art of the stage machinist than on that of the poet."
--Aristotle
#5

re: Rosie on WTC 7 and O'Reilly et al's Response

Papa, Popular Mechanics is just presenting more of the same. Read down to the comments you will see.

This is the same garbage the 9/11 Commission presented to my family. My brother perished on 9/11/01. Here it is 2006 and we don't have a damn clue as to what really happened on that horrific day. Bipartisn? Hardly!

The 9/11 Commission is seemingly an even bigger cover-up. Our families want answers, and we want to know why it happened. We want Osama brought to justice. Bush/Rice should have been impeached immediately for their mistakes and mishandling of everything leading up to that day.

My family has been outraged for so long I don't think we feel anything anymore. Rosie's words don't hurt us; they make us feel alive again. Like our story and the truth is not hidden and justice will prevail. People like O'Reilly assume they can speak for our families or the victims. The problem with him is that he comes at it with an agenda. It's an extremely touchy subject, but I can tell you one thing. Pandering to the families of 9/11 or using it as a political device is starting to reach a breaking point.
#6

re: Rosie on WTC 7 and O'Reilly et al's Response

You want to talk about conspiracy?

How come Old St. Paul's Church, located right across the street from the towers, suffered absolutely NO damage?

I think the entire 9/11 attack was orchestrated by Christian Conservatives! The buildings were all rigged to collapse in just such a way that no debris would fall on the church!

And think how many of the people working in those towers were Jews and Muslims!
#7

re: Rosie on WTC 7 and O'Reilly et al's Response

See it's garbage like that Jon, that make our voices meaningless.

Paljoey sorry for the slip... i forgot about that papa... but i can call u that right?
#9

re: Rosie on WTC 7 and O'Reilly et al's Response

You know, the problem with conspiracy theories is that it's impossible to discuss them without sounding crazy. Rosie needs no help to sound crazy anytime, so she sounds really crazy in this escapade. Does she ever say WHY someone wanted to demolish building 7?

And yeah, Rosie, fire melts steel every day. Ever been to a steel mill?
#10

re: Rosie on WTC 7 and O'Reilly et al's Response

Well what sucks in this country is that saying obvious things like "The Iraq War is about OIL." Is considered a conspiracy theory.
#11

re: Rosie on WTC 7 and O'Reilly et al's Response

I will believe Rosie as soon as she finishes her degree in structural engineering. 7WTC collapsed at around 5:30 in the afternoon, at which point the damage to the building and the flammable liquids stored in the building had been ongoing since 9 in the morning.
#12

re: Rosie on WTC 7 and O'Reilly et al's Response

First of all, let me say that I used to love Rosie. That was a few years ago. Personally, I don't buy into her conspiracy theory, and I think she has become nothing but a polarizing figure. Now, I have absolutely no love for her current nemesis, Bill O'Reilly, either. I think they are both megalomaniacs.
"It does me no injury for my neighbour to say there are 20 gods or no god. It neither picks my pocket, nor breaks my leg." -- Thomas Jefferson
#14

re: Rosie on WTC 7 and O'Reilly et al's Response

It's a shame she even brought this up. Her point was about Iran. She never said to "believe" her, she said to go out and research for yourself.



Do any of you remember when the 2004/2006 elections were peppered with "newly discovered" 9/11 tapes. Even down to simple tricks like that, the GOP used fear mongering to get votes and support.

How do you think it feels to never know if a family member had a last phone call? Something tells me every 911 call was logged and stored. Why couldn't they all be released simultaneously? They certainly weren't and still are not all out.


Our own government used cheap tricks to garner votes. It's disgusting. Rosie is just asking people to think twice. What choice do we have now? More kool-aid?


#15

re: Rosie on WTC 7 and O'Reilly et al's Response

I think the problem people have with both this theory and the Kennedy assassination is that many people simply refuse to believe that the American government would ever attack its own people. If you can suspend that notion, then you can begin to think critically about other points of view.

The reasons for the government to stage the 9/11 attack are numerous:


1. Gives the war industry a reason to make money
2. Creates a set of new enemies, fomenting war business around the world
3. Fearful citizens will be more willing to give up rights for security, paving the way for the Patriot Act, which in turn helps to criminalize any activity or person who opposes the government, which in turn strengthens the power of the government and cements the power of the rich.

I'm not saying I believe the 9/11 theory, but I don't NOT believe it either.

There is very little that America could or would do that would surprise me.
#17

re: Rosie on WTC 7 and O'Reilly et al's Response

I don't know PJ--but why would the government purposely give men syphllis? Or test cancer agents on soldiers? Or allow small kids to work in factories where they get limbs ripped off? Or lead a country into war on false pretenses?
#18

re: Rosie on WTC 7 and O'Reilly et al's Response

I am no fan of the American government's recent actions, but the idea that 7WTC was intentionally demolished seems so far fetched.
#19

re: Rosie on WTC 7 and O'Reilly et al's Response

"I will believe Rosie as soon as she finishes her degree in structural engineering. 7WTC collapsed at around 5:30 in the afternoon, at which point the damage to the building and the flammable liquids stored in the building had been ongoing since 9 in the morning."

Rosie NEVER said this is what she cold-hard believes. She says it is POSSIBLE. She said she DOESN'T KNOW FOR SURE. She said she wants to bring EXPERTS onto the show who DO know. She has a NOTION that it is possible the 9/11 is covering something. She said to FIND OUT THE FACTS FOR YOURSELF THEN have YOUR OWN opinion.

In that episode of THE VIEW, she was NOT shoving opinions down anyone's throats. She merely said she wants experts on the show to discuss what is possible and what is not possible.

And finally, it is not HER conspiracy. It's one that has been out for YEARS. She saw the documentary LOOSE CHANGE and has been looking up facts ever since to support (and counter support) what is reported to have happened during 9/11.

As for wiring up a building, here are some plausible possibilities:

- Years ago the building could have been wired in case of a take over or extreme emergency, in case a decision needed to be made to blow up the building.

- When the building was built, perhaps they rigged the building to make for an easy demolition in case they had to replace the building.

- Perhaps they did wire it on 9/10.

- Perhaps the planes and debris did bring down the building.

All four of those are very possibilities. Most people believe it is the fourth. But before the incident happened, I betcha scientists and the government would say it would be impossible to bring that building down.
"The Spectacle has, indeed, an emotional attraction of its own, but, of all the parts, it is the least artistic, and connected least with the art of poetry. For the power of Tragedy, we may be sure, is felt even apart from representation and actors. Besides, the production of spectacular effects depends more on the art of the stage machinist than on that of the poet."
--Aristotle
#20

re: Rosie on WTC 7 and O'Reilly et al's Response

Yeah, JoeKev, fire does melt steel every day, but it's under a controlled setting in a factory--most bulidings that catch fire do not collapse to the ground--none of the homes that burned in the recent spate of fires here in NYC have fallen down and they were far less secure.

As I said, I'm not convinced, but I still haven't heard a good explanation why they came down as they did.

It LOOKED like a demolition job, right? I'm not sayin, I'm just sayin....
#21

re: Rosie on WTC 7 and O'Reilly et al's Response

There is also the "missing plane" at the Pentagon. Though I don't know enough about the logistics of those incidents to come to any real conclusion myself, there are blatent cover-ups and mishandlings of 9/11. Those should be brought to light and not forgotten.

Also look at Bush's reaction with that goat book. And then to have a loser like Giliani come and steal the spotlight. I guess in the end he got his wars with Iran and Iraq. And the beat goes on...
#22

re: Rosie on WTC 7 and O'Reilly et al's Response

"But before the incident happened, I betcha scientists and the government would say it would be impossible to bring that building down. "

And therein lies the conspiracy.
#24

re: Rosie on WTC 7 and O'Reilly et al's Response

It seems to me that all Rosie is doing is asking questions.


Do not allow yourself to be spoon-fed information by the government or mainstream news media.

Ask Questions.

Seek (and when necessary DEMAND) Answers.

Examine the Evidence and CONSIDER THE SOURCE.

Speak Up and Speak Out.

And never let ANYONE tell you that by doing so means you’re being un-American or unpatriotic.


Updated On: 4/3/07 at 05:30 PM

#25

re: Rosie on WTC 7 and O'Reilly et al's Response

You don't have to get on the train, Rose.

The article does "explain" some things, but here's a thought--what if both sides were right? Like framing a guilty man?

And here's the REAL question: Who benefits from the conspiracy and who would suffer if it was proven true?

That's why these theories stick around--not because they're SO believable, but that the people who benefit from the theories being discounted are the same people in power who want the theories to stick.

You have to think about who benefits from a false story--like the Pearl Harbor attack--it was in America's best interests to be in WWII but public opinion would not tolerate it--until after Pearl Harbor.

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $60
Hot Show
Tickets From $71