Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

The Oscars: Do they matter anymore?

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#1

The Oscars: Do they matter anymore?

Not very, according to Joe Queenan in the LA Times.

(The following summary is from The Week:)

"Every year the Academy heaps laurels on 'widely ignored,' high-minded films (Half Nelson and Pan's Labyrinth, anyone?) while snubbing the movies that people actually pay to see, such as King Kong and Meet the Fockers XV.

When you gather a roomful of pretentious types, all of whom think they're artists, no one wants to admit that the 'face of the industry is Adam Sandler and Aston Kutcher,' rather than Helen Mirren and Daniel Day-Lewis.

The Oscars have become an exercise in professional amnesia--'the night when the industry gets tanked up and forgets what it does for a living.'

LINK to full article in the Times
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22

Updated On: 3/5/07 at 08:42 AM

#3

re: The Oscars: Do they matter anymore?

...meaning he's right?

I agree.

Not that the Oscars should be a popularity contest.

But when they are constantly an "anti-popularity contest," that IS pretentious and represents a resounding disconnect with what they actually do for a living.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22

Updated On: 3/5/07 at 08:44 AM

#4

re: The Oscars: Do they matter anymore?

And what they may not realize yet is that they are killing their highest industry honor... because it's mattering less and less each year to the people who buy movie tickets.

"There is no glory without an audience."
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22
#5

re: The Oscars: Do they matter anymore?

Maybe if Multiplexes all over would actually show more of the movies in release so people would have the opportunity to see them, rather than showing Ghost Rider on five screens, people might be more interested in watching The Oscars.

Those less-than-Blockbuster movies do well in the theaters they actually are allowed to play in, they suffer from not being able to penetrate a lot of markets that won't go beyond the big easy money first weekend pictures that appeal mostly to the 25 and under crowd.

The goal shouldn't be to dilute the Oscar pool, the goal should be to get more movies into more theaters.

Adults might go to more movies if they were fairly certain the movies were actually intended for them.

Updated On: 3/5/07 at 08:54 AM

#6

re: The Oscars: Do they matter anymore?

Well, apparently they don't see a profit in putting "Half Nelson" into the Cinema 14 in Tongonoxie, Kansas.

You've decided the audience should see what's good for them.

The audience, however, has already decided they want the artistic equivalent of a "Whopper with cheese and chili fries" instead. And they're the ones paying the admission price.


"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22

Updated On: 3/5/07 at 08:59 AM

#7

re: The Oscars: Do they matter anymore?

I think most people realize that the Academy honors excellence over popularity. I think an Oscar is still recognized as the highest accolade one can achieve in the film industry.
I'm not saying I always agree with their choices, but once you're nominated it becomes a permanent prefix to your introduction.
....but the world goes 'round
#8

re: The Oscars: Do they matter anymore?

No, I didn't remotely say the audience should see what's good for them. I'm saying movies with low distribution that do good per screen averages in smaller distribution might do well in larger distribution as well, but many theaters simply aren't interested in putting in movies that aren't popcorn movies or that have a smaller, albeit more consistent long term business.

Nowhere am I implying that we should force people to see movies they don't want to see to illuminate themselves, why are you putting words in my mouth? I'm saying people don't have the opportunity to see a lot of more versatile movies that are successful in other markets because theater owners won't bring them in to their market. These movies do well on DVD because in many cases it's the first opportunity people have to see them.

This constant insinuation in articles like this that no one outside New York, LA or Chicago are sophisticated enough to want or appreciate non-Hollywood spoon fed movies is downright insulting.

Updated On: 3/5/07 at 09:11 AM

#9

re: The Oscars: Do they matter anymore?

"It perpetuates the stereotype that all yokels are hicks." -- Lisa Simpson
Twitter @NamoInExile Instagram none
#10

re: The Oscars: Do they matter anymore?

There was that hilarious and ghastly thing that Chris Rock did for the Oscars a few years ago, when he paid a visit to the local Magic Johnson Cinema with a camera crew, asking patrons questions. None of them had seen or even heard of the nominated films, and several cited ALIEN VS. PREDATOR as the best movie of the year.

As for the grand delusion that the Oscars honor excellence, well, any group that nominates Clint Eastwood for Best Actor TWICE cannot really sustain that pretense for long. Considering the drivel that has won in the past few years (A BEAUTIFUL MIND, MILLION DOLLAR BABY, AMERICAN BEAUTY, the unspeakable Very Special Episode of the Love Boat known as CRASH, and above all the hideous monstrosity CHICAGO) while films of real quality and intelligence have been overlooked (AMERICAN SPLENDOR, BEFORE SUNSET, CHILDREN OF MEN, etc.) I just can't take them seriously as "mattering" at all.

Clint Eastwood: two Oscars for Best Director.
Alfred Hitchcock: none.




"If they can get you asking the wrong questions, they don't have to worry about the answers." Thomas Pynchon, GRAVITY'S RAINBOW "Reality is that which, when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away." Philip K. Dick My blog: http://www.roscoewrites.blogspot.com/

Updated On: 3/5/07 at 09:22 AM

#11

re: The Oscars: Do they matter anymore?

Here's the irony of it all...

The Oscar IS a peer award, you're right. It is supposed to (and okay, DOES) represent what the industry thinks of as "outstanding." It's not a popularity contest or a critics award. It's not for the people, by the people, or of the people. It's given by select industry members TO select industry members.

And the reason the award was created was to unify the industry, and promote excellence throughout the industry.

Yet the industry itself was created for public consumption... It wouldn't be an industry otherwise. There would be no "show business" without an audience buying tickets.

And right away, their little self-congratulating award and its 15-minute banquet ceremony turned into another "show." The public was invited to watch them (or initially listen to them or read about them via radio and newspaper) congratulating themselves on achieving excellence.

So, in that quick instance... the award and the ceremony became hypocritical. This is for US, damn it... but you, the audience, can watch... you will watch... you MUST watch... because now when we give these gold statues out, revenues for those films go UP. People buy more tickets to what we think is "good."

Unfortunately, the industry has changed over the years. There was a natural weeding out, prior to DVD/VHS screeners, in that really small films that never saw the light of day, never had many voters attending screenings either. Many of them fell by the wayside as "lost or undiscovered." Now, members are sent dozens of screeners for films that played just one week in one theatre in Los Angeles (the minimum eligibility requirement for consideration). And they are encouraged and sometimes expected to see as many of them as possible. Something that never was expected of them a decade or two ago, when it was physically impossible. (Not that it isn't physically impossible now to watch 300 DVD screeners either.)

So the separation has grown wider... more "little films that nobody knows" are being recognized and honored when the envelops are opened. And more TV viewers are scratching their heads and saying, I have NO idea what that is, or who that is. And the self-congratulatory award is meaning less and less to the audience... and they're not running out the day after Oscar Night and renting Half Nelson, or attending Pan's Labyrinth or Little Children, because it doesn't mean anything to them in the first place.

And the Academy holds its head high anyway and says, "well this award isn't for YOU. It's about what WE think is good." And then they pretend not to care when their bestowing of the golden statues doesn't turn into significant box office revenue. But they DO care deeply, and they know that's WHY the award means so much to them. It's not for excellence, and hasn't been since the first or second ceremony over 75 years ago. It's revered because of its potential profits after it is given. Because of future jobs that it might bring them. Because they can ask for bigger paychecks the next time around, or juicier roles, because they THINK people will now pay more to see their respected work.

And that's where they're WRONG, more and more, each year. The disconnect is growing wider.

"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22

Updated On: 3/5/07 at 09:36 AM

#12

re: The Oscars: Do they matter anymore?

B12B you are right. But don't most people watch the Oscars for the glamour of it all. It's a fantasy. Any profession can have an award for excellence, but who cares? Best Stenographer?
I read an interesting piece in a book that lists all the winners (I'll cite the source tonight, it's on my nightstand)where the author says the Academy likes to think they make movies of vital importance. The avarage film industry employee works all day on movies like Kindergarten Cop (it's an old book) and then tries to give the impression that they make socially responsible "message" films.
It's very symbiotic, they need to feel glamorous and important, and we want them to be that way.
Edit-here is the book:
re: The Oscars: Do they matter anymore?

Edit 2-wow, I didn't think it would be so small. Author is John Harkness
....but the world goes 'round

Updated On: 3/5/07 at 09:44 AM

#13

re: The Oscars: Do they matter anymore?

"It's very symbiotic, they need to feel glamorous and important, and we want them to be that way."

You're right, tazber. Or at least you WERE right. The audience WANTS (or WANTED) Hollywood to feel glamorous and important and to support their own fantasy. We like to see them parading around living the oh-so-definite DREAM. But at least audiences were aware of the films and work being honored (outstanding or not).

Now, they don't even know the work, the films or the people involved in this "glamorous fantasy of importance." There's no reason for them to care, beyond the red carpet parade. What happens during the ceremony doesn't really matter to them.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22
#14

re: The Oscars: Do they matter anymore?

Explains Sinno, "the number of cities where documentary films must screen to qualify for an Academy Award is being increased by 75%. This will make it much more difficult for independent filmmakers work to qualify for the Best Documentary Feature Award, while giving an advantage to films distributed by large studios. Fewer controversial films will qualify for Academy consideration, and my film Iraq in Fragments would have been disqualified this year."

http://www.alternet.org/mediaculture/48801/
"The gods who nurse this universe think little of mortals' cares. They sit in crowds on exclusive clouds and laugh at our love affairs. I might have had a real romance if they'd given me a chance. I loved him, but he didn't love me. I wanted him, but he didn't want me. Then the gods had a spree and indulged in another whim. Now he loves me, but I don't love him." - Cole Porter
#16

re: The Oscars: Do they matter anymore?

JohnPopa---The movie theatre owners, not the studios, decide what movies they show in their theatres. That monopoly (of studio owned theatre chains) was broken up back in the '50s.

If you're complaining about five theatres showing the same crappy movie, that's because the theatre owners know the "artistic" movies don't sell well.

And the artistic smaller films DO cost more to put into the theatres, which is another misconception. This is a "bulk rate" business. If they have 3,000 prints of a major studio film, it costs less to show (per print and per screen) than if they made 300 copies of an indy film and have to share it across the country.

That's why the "artistic" movies aren't showing in the smaller communities. They're not good for business. Per-screen average hype means nothing other than a potential indication of what a major movie going into wide release MIGHT do when it opens. And lately, the per-screen initial averages for tiered-release films have proven to be way off. Which is why the tiered release strategy hasn't been working well lately.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22
#17

re: The Oscars: Do they matter anymore?

Where did I imply the studios were the ones making these decisions? In fact, I thought my post that said "I'm saying people don't have the opportunity to see a lot of more versatile movies that are successful in other markets because theater owners won't bring them in to their market" I was pretty squarely blaming it on theater owners, hence the use of the term 'theater owners.'
#18

re: The Oscars: Do they matter anymore?

By that logic, the Tonys should always been given to the Mamma Mias and Wickeds and Disney shows instead of the Passions and Light in the Piazzas.

Awards like criticism attempt to raise the bar of the artform by honoring the best--regardless of what the popular masses like as stereotypically the masses don't have good taste. If you want the other, there's the MTV Movie Awards and the People's Choice Awards.

We can debate whether or not the Oscars get it right every year. But, I agree they strive to honor the best.
johnraymondbarker.com
#19

re: The Oscars: Do they matter anymore?

I was in this tiny walled city in Croatia last week...and their movie theater had just finished a run of all the Oscar nominees. So I think they are still recognized as honoring some of the best movies in cinema, even if they don't always get it right.
#20

re: The Oscars: Do they matter anymore?

It seems that the Oscars in the past couple of years have become less financially relevant in some ways -- this year for the first time in recent memory, none of the Top 10 movies at the box office during Oscar weekend or for the weekend after were nominees in any category, Crash was the lowest-grossing Best Picture winner since 1988, and The Last King of Scotland is likely to end up being the lowest-grossing Best Actor movie for quite a while -- but in general, the Oscars reward critically acclaimed movies that are also box office hits, just like the Grammys/Emmmys/Tonys do. The Academy might be moving away from that trend, but I'm not sure that's a bad thing.
"What was the name of that cheese that I like?" "you can't run away forever...but there's nothing wrong with getting a good head start" "well I hope and I pray, that maybe someday, you'll walk in the room with my heart"
#21

re: The Oscars: Do they matter anymore?

I don't think the Oscars EVER mattered in that sense. The Academy Awards started out as an evening of self-congratulation and self-promotion for the Hollywood film industry and so it stays. They have rarely if ever rewarded either the most commercially successful films/artists OR the most critically praised or important/influential. The string of artists who have never won an award who have made an important impact on filmmaking is long and storied.

I think you could probably make a good case that the most important category at the Academy Awards is Best Publicist.
#22

re: The Oscars: Do they matter anymore?

They still hold prestige. And, no matter what someone thinks of their choices, they always will.

Would someone whether have an Oscar or a People's Choice Award?
That answer is easy.
"One no longer loves one's insight enough once one communicates it."

The opposite of creation isn't war, it's stagnation.
#23

re: The Oscars: Do they matter anymore?

The films & stars are not of a caliber they were years ago

The ceremony used to be fun to watch. Now they are just BORING
Poster Emeritus

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $70
Hot Show
Tickets From $58
Hot Show
Tickets From $67