Here's the irony of it all...
The Oscar IS a peer award, you're right. It is supposed to (and okay, DOES) represent what the industry thinks of as "outstanding." It's not a popularity contest or a critics award. It's not for the people, by the people, or of the people. It's given by select industry members TO select industry members.
And the reason the award was created was to unify the industry, and promote excellence throughout the industry.
Yet the industry itself was created for public consumption... It wouldn't be an industry otherwise. There would be no "show business" without an audience buying tickets.
And right away, their little self-congratulating award and its 15-minute banquet ceremony turned into another "show." The public was invited to watch them (or initially listen to them or read about them via radio and newspaper) congratulating themselves on achieving excellence.
So, in that quick instance... the award and the ceremony became hypocritical. This is for US, damn it... but you, the audience, can watch... you will watch... you MUST watch... because now when we give these gold statues out, revenues for those films go UP. People buy more tickets to what we think is "good."
Unfortunately, the industry has changed over the years. There was a natural weeding out, prior to DVD/VHS screeners, in that really small films that never saw the light of day, never had many voters attending screenings either. Many of them fell by the wayside as "lost or undiscovered." Now, members are sent dozens of screeners for films that played just one week in one theatre in Los Angeles (the minimum eligibility requirement for consideration). And they are encouraged and sometimes expected to see as many of them as possible. Something that never was expected of them a decade or two ago, when it was physically impossible. (Not that it isn't physically impossible now to watch 300 DVD screeners either.)
So the separation has grown wider... more "little films that nobody knows" are being recognized and honored when the envelops are opened. And more TV viewers are scratching their heads and saying, I have NO idea what that is, or who that is. And the self-congratulatory award is meaning less and less to the audience... and they're not running out the day after Oscar Night and renting Half Nelson, or attending Pan's Labyrinth or Little Children, because it doesn't mean anything to them in the first place.
And the Academy holds its head high anyway and says, "well this award isn't for YOU. It's about what WE think is good." And then they pretend not to care when their bestowing of the golden statues doesn't turn into significant box office revenue. But they DO care deeply, and they know that's WHY the award means so much to them. It's not for excellence, and hasn't been since the first or second ceremony over 75 years ago. It's revered because of its potential profits after it is given. Because of future jobs that it might bring them. Because they can ask for bigger paychecks the next time around, or juicier roles, because they THINK people will now pay more to see their respected work.
And that's where they're WRONG, more and more, each year. The disconnect is growing wider.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22
Updated On: 3/5/07 at 09:36 AM