A word of caution: don't base your school choice on alumni and what kind of career they're having now. While that's always nice to know--I know I secretly revel in the fact that Sondheim and Bill Finn went where I go--just remember that for every alumni who's been able to break into the business, there are also plenty of alumni from these places who haven't been able to. Like others have said earlier in this thread, a lot of this business is about who you know, and about being in the right place at the right time.
That said, good luck hunting for schools! It's a very scary and exciting thing all at the same time. Try to enjoy it.
Starstruck, for schools in the NY area, Wagner College is on Staten Island and has a really wonderful program. Also, SUNY Purchase and, to a lesser extent, SUNY New Paltz are worth looking into. Check out the Rutgers Mason Gross School of the Arts in NJ, too. And someone already mentioned Marymount Manhattan. It all depends on what you're looking for.
But if you kiss me,
If we touch,
Warning's fair:
I don't care
Very much