Well, I'm certainly not going to argue about DOUBT (Jerby will be along any second, I'm sure

) However, not everything is like that - at least in my experience. Some recent outings that have proven very enjoyable:
The Goat at the Taper.
Cyrano at SCR.
Take Me Out at the Geffen.
Enchanted April at Pasadena Playhouse.
That's just one example from each of those venues.
Plus, they've really worked at establishing a section of Santa Monica Blvd. as kind of LA's 'Off-Broadway.' We've seen some wonderful 99-seat productions in those theatres. There's been some good work done at Anteus (a recent Mother Courage that was well-received, for example.)
Also, between SCR and the new Kirk Douglas, there's a great focus on new works here that is invigorating - and has led (from SCR, at least) to some great new plays - including The Clean House, by Sarah Ruhl (a Pulitzer finalist this year.)
I don't disagree that some of the work here can be frustrating - we've left at intermission on more than one occasion - and from some of these very theatres. However, that is a possiblity anywhere, and it's not like I don't think they're at least trying.