Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Is Marie Christine Worth Buying? — Page 2

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#26

re: Is Marie Christine Worth Buying?



"I'm not sure how someone can be miscast in a show that was written specifically for them (both in character and voice) and there is not a single moment she was "inadequate". That is ludicrous."

Not only NOT ludicrous but a matter of fact when the actress is given nothing to play, fails to provide her own modus operandi to generate the play, and whose portrayal of an outsize, mythic figure resembles nothing so much as a little girl trying on Mommy's clothes. In addition, part of McDonald's appeal to audiences and fame can be attributed to the warmth, ebullience and generosity of her persona. It's an understatement to say that MARIE-CHRISTINE offers no opportunities for its leading lady to display any of those qualities and, consequently, McDonald was not only inadequate but miscast.


Updated On: 5/1/08 at 09:04 PM

#27

re: Is Marie Christine Worth Buying?

"In addition, part of McDonald's appeal to audiences and fame can be attributed to the warmth, ebullience and generosity of her persona"...............?!?!!?!?
What planet are you on MM??? I have yet to see a performer as heartwrenching and be as convincingly enraged as Audra. She plays mad very VERY well...listen to "Tell Me" and tell me that she's miscast! I can respect that the show wasn't for your taste but your arguments are stupid and make no sense. Speaking just from the CD her performance (as with everything this women does) was nothing less than power house. I cannot think of many other actresses that could pull off this role...which as someone stated earlier was freaking written FOR HER! She pulls off the impossible on the CD she made me terrified of her, made my heart go out for her and understand where she was coming from all at the same time. And that crap about the score...i don't know what that was about but find me a score as complex with as many levels...i'm sorry but whoever said you had to think really hard and focus to "get it" but i was in sixth grade when i first heard this score and i LOVED it...granted i'm a theater nerd but i got it and bawled listening to the cd ... it was an experience it was very cool how you get a feel of the show with the CD i think it was perfectly made because its very easy to follow even without the synopsis which is included thank you powers that be. But the songs are amazing and unlike anything you will hear nowadays on a cast recording. What audra wears bears nothing on wether you should get the CD! and the pics that i saw of the show looked very nice and period. But back to the amazing score, it sucks you into the story and moves you...seriously i cannot reccomend it enough it may not be your style but appreciate that its an incredible score. Audra is at an all time high here people she will hold you with this performance in an amazing grasp and she never lets go and yes i agree that the last chorus will BLOW your mind! LaChushia is an amazing guy and i can't wait to hear what he produces next!
RIP Natasha Richardson. ~You were a light on this earth ~
#28

re: Is Marie Christine Worth Buying?

I just received it today - finally...though I had it through AOL's free trial of MusicNet.

What a difference it makes once you have the lyrics and most of the stage directions.

Also, I started to notice all the little nuances and repetitions in music.

Also, I just read Medea and the show makes so much more sense now. It is amazing how he changed Medea into Marie Christine.

I think I prefer MC to Medea...but I do miss a father being chopped up and boiled to make him younger re: Is Marie Christine Worth Buying? Just kidding.

Anyway, amazing.
#29

re: Is Marie Christine Worth Buying?

This show is frickin' golden. Audra is in top form vocally for this one. This CD is one of my favs...always in rotation.

Quick side note: Yes, Audra was great in this show, but...Heather Headley was undeniably brilliant in Aida, and gave an historic performance. Challenging her Tony win is not only wrong, but rediculous.
"Fundamentalism means never having to say 'I'm wrong.'" -- unknown
#30

re: Is Marie Christine Worth Buying?

YES. The score is amazing.
"If you are going to do something, do it well. And leave something witchy." -Charlie Manson
#31

re: Is Marie Christine Worth Buying?

touchme - then I don't wanna be right re: Is Marie Christine Worth Buying?

No, Heather vs. Audra - good match.

But there is no question this score is better than Aida's. This score is better than most shows'.
#32

re: Is Marie Christine Worth Buying?

"Yes, Audra was great in this show, but...Heather Headley was undeniably brilliant in Aida, and gave an historic performance. Challenging her Tony win is not only wrong, but rediculous."

I saw both performances the same week. Audra gave a mature layered exquisite performance providing a vast range vocally and emotionally. Heather belted like a champ, but her acting and physicality were quite immature, her emotional range was limited (due in part to the writing) and her dialogue was mumbled to the point of indistinction and spoken with the same affected stress to virtually every sentence. I was sorely disappointed and genuinely puzzled by her Tony win over Toni and Audra. Audra's performance was "historic" as far as I was concerned, taking the stage in 90% of what was virtually a modern opera. Sherie Rene Scott was the only actor who impressed me in Aida and the only reason I stayed for the second act. One man's ridiculous is another man's reality.
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian
#33

re: Is Marie Christine Worth Buying?

"who can pretty much do no wrong if she burped the songs."

Now, that I would pay money to see.
when ducks grow thumbs then maybe my opinion will change.

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $70
Hot Show
Tickets From $58
Hot Show
Tickets From $67