"Yes, Audra was great in this show, but...Heather Headley was undeniably brilliant in Aida, and gave an historic performance. Challenging her Tony win is not only wrong, but rediculous."
I saw both performances the same week. Audra gave a mature layered exquisite performance providing a vast range vocally and emotionally. Heather belted like a champ, but her acting and physicality were quite immature, her emotional range was limited (due in part to the writing) and her dialogue was mumbled to the point of indistinction and spoken with the same affected stress to virtually every sentence. I was sorely disappointed and genuinely puzzled by her Tony win over Toni and Audra. Audra's performance was "historic" as far as I was concerned, taking the stage in 90% of what was virtually a modern opera. Sherie Rene Scott was the only actor who impressed me in Aida and the only reason I stayed for the second act. One man's ridiculous is another man's reality.
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian