Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom? — Page 2

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#26

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

a pity nom? how sad. It's fine that Charlotte got nominated, but it sucks that she took up a spot that could be given to others.

I didn't think Charlotte was that great, and I felt like she was probably nominated more for her role than her performance.

I didn't enjoy Charlotte's performance either. She was supposed to dance in "Music and the Mirror" as if she would never dance again, and had to dance to in order to live... but did not. Maybe I saw her on an off night.

It's an interesting thought that someone who played a role previously could both be a threat to a new actor taking on the same role, as well make that role iconic and attention-worthy.
#27

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

i also think walsh was robbed, though i definitely agree that heather laws was phenomenal as well and deserving of a nomination (though she really only made an impact in that *one* song, whereas walsh was more of a presence throughout the show).

i can tell you that she keeps getting better, because i liked her Ladies Who Lunch rendition that i saw on the site that goes unnamed, but i was completely unprepared so be so blown away when I saw her live at the Barrymore a few weeks ago.

#28

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

Barbara definitely deserved a nomination over Charlotte. I was completely numb after "Ladies Who Lunch," I thought she was that affecting. It was a brilliant performance and it really caught me by surprise. Her moments with Raul are easily the best moments of the show, except for "Being Alive" of course.

~Steven
#29

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?


2. Barbara has a bad rep--I remember posting about her lackluster performance in HAIRSPRAY and someone called her Barbara Wash-Out. I think she has a tendency to walk through performances--whether or not it's true, it's a small theatre world and that stuff gets around

- HAIRSPRAY has absolutely noting to do with her performance in COMPANY. I doubt most of the Tony voters even saw her in Hairspray, considering she was just a replacement. I've never heard anyone say she walked through Joanne. And quite frankly I think Joanne is a 10 million times better role than Velma in HAIRSPRAY. And no offense, I think Hairspray is great - BUT LADIES WHO LUNCH is probally better than any song in Hairspray's entire score. I don't think any actress could get bored playing Joanne every night. There is no comparison between her material she had in Hairspray and the material she has Company right now.

Updated On: 5/21/07 at 05:06 PM

#31

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

Wow, one thing i know is that she definitely does NOT walk through her performance as Joanne.

I also talked to Leenya, who was told that they are supposed to be in character, even when they play their instruments or are sitting upstage. Maybe this also requires them to remain in character and to be on their toes the entire show.
#32

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

Any "reputation" I've ever heard of Walsh developing has been because of her off stage antics, not her on stage habits (she's one of the most dedicated and hard working performers treading the boards today.)
Tonya Pinkins: Then we had a "Lot's Wife" last June that was my personal favorite. I'm still trying to get them to let me sing it at some performance where we get to sing an excerpt that's gone.
Tony Kushner: You can sing it at my funeral.
#34

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

i thought she was great. i think that in such a huge role like joanne it is easy to get looked over, like thinking that the part shines through instead of the actress.

i wish company would have gotten more noms. i think i've had about enough of spring awakening hype (*GASP*)
#37

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

*SPOILER*


I think it is a tribute to Walsh that her first line to Bobby after LADIES WHO LUNCH has elicited a gasp of shock from the audience the three times I have seen this production. I never saw Stritch but I could not for the life of me picture her asking Bobby that question - she was eccentric and (for me) asexual, whereas Barbara is both aggressive and protective. Should have been nominated. I was not aware of any "history" associated with her, I am that naive.
#40

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

Well the editing of Walsh's part may have hurt.
I think she was fine till her big number which I think landed flat.
And Doyle's direction robbed her of applause.
She did not deserve a nom this year.
Stritchie had nothing to do with it.

One of Joanne's best lines
"You just blew it"
is gone.
You have to set up her interest in the younger guys.
#41

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

CPD - there is plenty of basis for Joanne's interest in younger men, and Bobby in particular. At one point she says something like (I don't have the book with me) - "I catch him looking and looking, and I just look right back."
#42

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

I think people are still pissed LADIES WHO LUNCH doesn't have a orchestral ending. But it makes it so much BETTER for Joanne as a character. She's losing it, she's breaking down, and she's drunk. It works perfectly. Her LADIES blows me away.

#44

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

Doyle's direction didn't rob her of the applause; it was her choice and he liked it. You don't have to agree with the choice, but you can't blame Doyle for everything you don't approve of.

On another note, how much older is Joanne actually supposed to be? The power balance in that relationship is so fascinating.
A work of art is an invitation to love.
#45

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

I also think it's a shame that Barbara Walsh didn't get nominated.

I loved her interpretation of The Ladies Who Lunchs. And... I know it's shocking to say this, but I like her's better than Stritch's.

"It's a goddamn beautiful day, shut up!"

Updated On: 5/21/07 at 10:46 PM

#47

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

Curtain, I believe Walsh has stated in an article that she made the choice and he liked it.
I am a firm believer in serendipity- all the random pieces coming together in one wonderful moment, when suddenly you see what their purpose was all along.
#48

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

Curtain, I believe Walsh has stated in an article that she made the choice and he liked it.
I am a firm believer in serendipity- all the random pieces coming together in one wonderful moment, when suddenly you see what their purpose was all along.
#49

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

Oh, yeah, that's the only way I could've gotten the information! Stop being such a wiseass. Good lord, you are worse than my little brother. It's readily available for people who care to be informed.

She talks about it in the link I posted over in that other thread. This one:

http://www.playbill.com/news/article/104244.html
A work of art is an invitation to love.

Updated On: 5/21/07 at 10:48 PM

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $60
Hot Show
Tickets From $71