Since the original post suggested that Elaine Stritch's performance was so memorable that it affected Barbara Walsh's lack of getting a Tony nomination, and the fact that Ethel Merman's stirring performance as Rose didn't prevent other Rose's from getting a Tony nomination, I wanted to post some actual Tony results:
In 1960 the nominees for best actress in a musical were:
Carol Burnett for ONCE UPON A MATTRESS
Dolores Gray for DESTRY RIDES AGAIN
Eileen Herlie for TAKE ME ALONG
Mary Martin for THE SOUND OF MUSIC*
Ethel Merman for GYPSY
And the winner was Mary Martin(!!!)
In 1971 the nominees for best actress in a musical were:
Susan Browning for COMPANY(playing April)
Sandy Duncan for THE BOY FRIEND
Helen Gallagher for NO, NO, NANETTE*
Elaine Stritch for COMPANY(playing Joanne)
And the winner was Helen Gallagher
In 1975 the nominees for best actress in a musical were:
Lola Falana for DOCTOR JAZZ
Angela Lansbury for GYPSY*
Bernadette Peters for MACK AND MABEL
Ann Reinking for GOODTIME CHARLEY
And the winner was Angela Lansbury
As was already mentioned, Tyne Daly won for best actress in a musical for GYPSY in 1991(?) I don't remember who she was up against.
Bernadette Peters was nominated for best actress in a musical for GYPSY in 2003 but did not win. Again, I don't remember who she was up against.
So, being memorable in a role doesn't stop others from getting a Tony nomination for playing the same role.
"Madam Rose...and her daughter...Gypsy!"
Updated On: 5/22/07 at 03:11 PM