Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom? — Page 3

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#51

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

Eh, I believe it. It's not something that'd make sense to lie about, but whatever. Thankfully I'm not that cynical. It must be really nice, though, to just toss out anything you don't like as false!

I'd never seen her in anything before. Hated her the first time I saw Company, but now I think she's wonderful.
A work of art is an invitation to love.

Updated On: 5/21/07 at 10:54 PM

#52

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

Yes Curtain, because her deciding not to have applause after the song just KILLED her chance at a nom.


I am a firm believer in serendipity- all the random pieces coming together in one wonderful moment, when suddenly you see what their purpose was all along.
#54

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

"On another note, how much older is Joanne actually supposed to be? The power balance in that relationship is so fascinating."

Hm, her line that says, "I hope I look as good as you when I'm your age" implies that she's younger than Bobby, no?
#56

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

She's joking when she says that. She references her "old" age a number of times, such as, "I know all the rules for birthday candle blowing; I've had enough or a wax museum."
A work of art is an invitation to love.

Updated On: 5/21/07 at 11:08 PM

#59

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

With the dialogue continuing without applause at the end of her powerful song still resounding in the theater, there is an uneasiness that reflects the terrible fact that in the face of such horrible self-realization, life still marches on. Heartlessly, and steadily.

I love this choice of not letting the audience applause after "Ladies Who Lunch".
#60

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

^ well said - I think it's haunting to end the song without the comfort of applause

One of Joanne's best lines "You just blew it" is gone.
Do you mean that literally? The line wasn't cut... or do you mean that she just doesn't deliver it well?
The morning star always gets wonderful bright the minute before it has to go --doesn't it?
#62

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

"HAIRSPRAY has absolutely noting to do with her performance in COMPANY. I doubt most of the Tony voters even saw her in Hairspray, considering she was just a replacement. I've never heard anyone say she walked through Joanne..... There is no comparison between her material she had in Hairspray and the material she has Company right now."

Wow--you totally misunderstood the point--what I meant was that when i saw her in HAIRSPRAY, she walked through it and I made mention of that in a post--someone else said she had been dubbed Barbara Wash-OUt by someone else entirely, which indicated to me that she had given less-than-stllar performances before--of perhaps it's due to some off-stage drama of which I'm unaware.

THIS is what gives her a bad rep amongst artists and if I heard it here, then I'm sure I'm not the first to hear of such things--the Bway community is VERY SMALL, believe it or not.

And I never said I tought she walked through COMPANY--just the reverse--I think she should have been nommed as well, but I think there were outside factors hat contributed to her omission, several of which I speculated.

Sheesh!
#63

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

Since the original post suggested that Elaine Stritch's performance was so memorable that it affected Barbara Walsh's lack of getting a Tony nomination, and the fact that Ethel Merman's stirring performance as Rose didn't prevent other Rose's from getting a Tony nomination, I wanted to post some actual Tony results:
In 1960 the nominees for best actress in a musical were:
Carol Burnett for ONCE UPON A MATTRESS
Dolores Gray for DESTRY RIDES AGAIN
Eileen Herlie for TAKE ME ALONG
Mary Martin for THE SOUND OF MUSIC*
Ethel Merman for GYPSY
And the winner was Mary Martin(!!!)

In 1971 the nominees for best actress in a musical were:
Susan Browning for COMPANY(playing April)
Sandy Duncan for THE BOY FRIEND
Helen Gallagher for NO, NO, NANETTE*
Elaine Stritch for COMPANY(playing Joanne)
And the winner was Helen Gallagher

In 1975 the nominees for best actress in a musical were:
Lola Falana for DOCTOR JAZZ
Angela Lansbury for GYPSY*
Bernadette Peters for MACK AND MABEL
Ann Reinking for GOODTIME CHARLEY
And the winner was Angela Lansbury

As was already mentioned, Tyne Daly won for best actress in a musical for GYPSY in 1991(?) I don't remember who she was up against.

Bernadette Peters was nominated for best actress in a musical for GYPSY in 2003 but did not win. Again, I don't remember who she was up against.

So, being memorable in a role doesn't stop others from getting a Tony nomination for playing the same role.







"Madam Rose...and her daughter...Gypsy!"

Updated On: 5/22/07 at 03:11 PM

#64

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

"And Doyle's direction robbed her of applause."

No it didn't! I'm assuming she got to bow? Who "needs" applause at the end of every song... besides--if you're blown away by a specific song, then clap after it! A director can't make you do anything.

As I've said before, I wish we'd return to the old days when we clapped when we LIKED something, not just because a song was over. Don't even get me started on standing O's....

Updated On: 5/22/07 at 06:02 PM

#65

re: Stritch the reason for Barbara Walsh's lack of a Tony nom?

Of course she got to bow, and when I saw it, she got great applause. I'm not sure if she got a standing ovation, but not even everyone stood for Raul - I was one of the few in my section.

As for the direction, it's the same way after Another Hundred People when Angel goes right into her line. Same with Sorry-Grateful to an extent. I think we've become accustomed to the after song applause/pause by the actors, but that type of thing usually doesnt happen in plays. I mean it sucks not to be able to applaud her performance after that song, but thats the reason for the curtain call.
The morning star always gets wonderful bright the minute before it has to go --doesn't it?

Updated On: 5/22/07 at 06:09 PM

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $60
Hot Show
Tickets From $80
Hot Show
Tickets From $58