Profile for Adeliciaboy

Uh-oh.   Has anyone listened to the just-released teaser tape of Audra singing the "Gypsy" score.  If you have heard it, you should be very worried about how this production is going to turn out.   As soon as I heard it, the first word that came to mind is "MISCAST!!"

The teaser immediately reminded me of the fatal mistake made in the original production of the ill-fated "Carrie" musical when Barbara Cook was cast as Carrie&#3

Would someone who has seen the show and commented favorably about the direction please explain to me how he or she reached that conclusion and still found the show flat and dull.  Unless I'm missing something, the responsibility of the director is to create a show that excites audiences rather than putting them to sleep. 

I also find it odd that there has been so little response  of any sort to the show on this board.  The Tammy Faye crowd is going bonkers posti

Please someone save me from total madness.  I was at the first preview tonight and all I have to say is what a horrid sack of excrement this whole endeavor is.  What nerve it took for the producers to haul this piece of pretentious nonsense into New York City, which has seen a steady stream, of disasters this past year.  But I’ve seen most of them and this is by far the worst.  The first 45 minutes of the 90 minute show is filled with salty sailors prancing arou

Bravo Distinctive Baritone!!  You quite accurately deciphered Chris Jones'. typically "supportive" review.  Jones is  incapable of directly saying a show doesn't work, especially when it's supposedly a Broadway bound vehicle.

  I'm sorry.  But one great performance  rom Ghee does not a successful musical make.  And I'm doubly sorry but a merely serviceable score also does not make a show successful.  No matter h

Sorry folks.  This musical won't become a success with the general public until the producers decide what this show wants to be.   Those going in expecting a musical based on "Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil" will be sorely disappointed.  Those expecting a drag cabaret act may have a more enjoyable time depending on how much they like Ghee.

Regardless of which way this show goes, Jason Robert Brown needs to step it up on the musical score front. &nb

Bartlett Sher????  you fellow posters are spot-on in questioning the sanity of those responsible for selecting this guy to direct Dolly's bio-musical.  It makes no sense.  Sher's not a pop culture type of guy for sure.  and I doubt he's ever listened to a country music song in his life.  If he has, I'm not aware he's ever communicated that publicly.  This sort of stupid move is exactly why Broadway is hanging by a thread.  Decisions

Yep, Chicago is fast getting a reputation as a try-out town for shows that — to put it mildly — need a whole lot of work.  The “Midnight” musical had great source material, no doubt about it.  But clearly the folks at the helm of this jumbled affair had no intention of even trying to be faithful to the source material.  Under director Rob Ashford and book writer Taylor Mac (an odd and ultimately bad choice for this job) this “Midnight” badly

Here's the orchestra breakdown:  Keyboards Ben Cohn and Cam Concur; Violin Michele Lukas; Violin and Viola Karla Gala; Cello Mark Lekas; Reeds Jim Gailloreto, Steve Leinheiser, David Orlicz, Jaco Slocum; Lead Trumpet Chuck Parish; Trumpet Josh Rzepka; Trombones Michael Joyce Tom Matt; French Horn Greg Flint; Guitar Steve Roberts; Bass Marc Hogan; Drum Damien Bassman; Percussion David Victor.

Altogether 18 personnel, but it sure doesn't sound like it in the theater.

Dear Betty:  I wouldn't be so sure they are going to do the massive amount of work needed to fix this turkey.  The bones to build from are simply NOT there.  Two and one-half hours of poorly done camp is not enough.  And right now, if one is being generous, that's all the creative team has got to work with.  I'm shocked that none of the posters  on this board -- or almost none -- are talking about the near total absence of a memorable &

Dear Broadway World message board readers.  Please allow me to inject a note of sanity into the several favorable reactions to this travesty’s first preview. I was there tonight too. First off, this is NOT a Broadway musical.  It’s a trashy Vegas comic act masquerading as theater.  The show has no coherent script and no music except for one 11 o’clock number sung by the two leading ladies that is so ridiculously over the top that you listen in d

Greetings fellow opening night review monitors.  If there is any justice left in the Broadway world  around Times Square  W4E should be declared a train wreck and dispatched to whatever graveyard is reserved for expensive theatrical disasters.   Rumors began circulating in the hours before opening that massive work had been done to improve  the show.  I was at the first preview and only a miracle could have made that show much more than a boring mediocrity.  

I was at Saturday’s first preview.  Let me get this off my chest first.  I for one am sick and tired of greedy producers in this post-pandemic world trying to pawn of their half-baked theatrical soufflés on a public that for the most part wouldn’t know a good musical from a pile of trash.  “W4E” most decidedly is in the latter category.   There are plenty of problems with this show.  Chief among them is Pigpen Theatre’s score, whic

Okay so now we know how the critics rated "Shucked."   Most chose to give it a thumbs up because of the humor they allegedly found in the show's threadbare book.  But to their discredit, these same critics also failed to note that the humor in "Shucked" cuts both ways.  Some may indeed find the jokes lough-out-loud hysterical, while others will find them anything but.  But all the humor in the world isn't going to change the real truth about &qu

Have the members of this board completely lost their collective minds???  I was at the show Wednesday night.  What is going down at the Nederlander Theatre under the guise of “Shucked” is nothing less than an unmitigated disaster.  What’s worse it’s an insult to the heart and soul of country music with a score that is truly duller than dishwasher.  I live in Nashville, so I have some idea of what the best of country can be.

Robert Horn’

Saw the show in previews 10 days ago.  Found it to be a flawed small musical  that wants to be a melodic, uplifting evening about true love and dementia -- two topics that quite frankly don't work well together on stage.  Some posters on this site believe  the show is ready for Broadway.  I wouldn't be so fast to say that.  Ingrid Michelson has written a few pleasant tunes, but like  the work  of other composers from the pop world who have tried

Suddenly the sorry "Prada" plot has thickened.   With  the musical now history in Chicago and much of the cast headed back to New York, word comes that Sir Elton John actually has another musical "Tammy Faye" about to open at London's Almeida Theatre in October. I don't recall much if anything being said about "Tammy Faye" in the lead-up to the "Prada" run in Chicago.  But the fact that Sir John had another show in the works may e

Saw the Wednesday evening preview with the Andy understudy.   Let’s cut to the chase fellow posters.  This show has big problems on multiple fronts — namely book, music, choreography and direction. Of those, the book and the music are the most pressing problems.  Elton John simply hasn’t written a score for this show.  There is no there there when it comes to the music.  If this show has any chance of succeeding, Sir John is going to have to come up