Big Fish I believe had mixed reviews. Michael Riedel kept talking about how it would be the first flop of the season, and he was right.
On a similar note, Bullets Over Broadway was proclaimed by Riedel to be a sure fire hit and it flopped.
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/27/14
fun thread
the most improbable hits IMO
Cats
Contact
Rent (a musical about junkies and aids...)
Next to normal
some surprising flops
Tarzan
Young Frankenstein
addams family
spiderman
Honeymoon in Vegas(likely goin down)
Bridges of madison county
lestat
Videos