Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!
#1

$99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

I was turning in an application for Dollars for Scholars this afternoon...and this girl had the receptionist on the phone with her dad about her EFC (expected financial contribution). The receptionist asked about a whole bunch of numbers and if they were correct. The father said yes every time. Then, she said, "Okay...if all of that is correct, as it says here, your EFC is $99,999...and that's more than the cost for your daughter's college." The father persisted in saying that he still wanted his daughter to be able to apply, etc. When the woman said, "Okay, I have seven students here waiting to speak with me," he finally gave in and got off the phone. Five minutes later, the girl's mother called. Honestly, my EFC is $5,305...and for some reason I feel a tiny bit offended that she would apply for my scholarship! =P

I guess I could understand extenuating circumstances, but aren't those supposed to be covered in the FAFSA? I just don't understand how a person whose family is expected to be able to pay $99,999 a year towards her college tuition would feel the need to apply for Dollars for Scholars...unless her parents simply won't pay. In that case, poo poo on them, and...get a job! Let me have my much-needed money!
#2

re: $99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

Wow, $100,000 towards school...thats ridiculous. I thought my mom's EFC of $20,000 was ridiculously high.
"Not everyone can come and go by bubble"
#3

re: $99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

I agree that most EFCs are outrageous. Mine is about a third of my parent's total income, and I still have a brother at home. There's no way that they could afford to pay what is estimated.

With scholarships, it really does suck that most of them aren't done by financial need but on merit. Unfortunately, that's how it works. I'm paying for half of my school with loans, so I know what you mean by being angry when people who don't really need the money apply for the same one as you.
#4

re: $99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

The situation is rough too though. The reality is most people cannot afford college without loans.

In Michigan most schools are about 12,000-15,000 dollars. Even if a family is making say 60,000 dollars a year (which statistically is optimistic) and lets say they had no taxes to pay (which is statistically IMPOSSIBLE) the amount of money college would cost would be a huge burden to that family.

The reality is college is hardly affordable for most people except the incredibly wealthy and those who are so impoverished that the government feels socially obligated to ensure they have the opportunity for education. (not trying to spark a political debate, just stating the facts)

This is probably why I will not be going to my #1 college, I was accepted, but it just doesn't sound like it is going to work money wise.
#5

re: $99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

Yeah...but your EFC is calculated after taking taxes, etc., into account. Le sigh. =/
#6

re: $99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

i don't want to start a huge controversy, but...

"With scholarships, it really does suck that most of them aren't done by financial need but on merit. Unfortunately, that's how it works."

There are plenty of purely financial scholarships and loan programs for those who can't afford college... looking just at the word, a scholarship is meant for an academic... one who has proven himself to be academically and intellectually qualified and talented. If you haven't worked hard enough in school to prove merit, why do you feel entitled to be handed money for college?
#7

re: $99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

I concur. I mean, I got a really nice scholarship to one of the schools I applied to based on merit, and basically I have a friend who was accepted as well, who got a nicer package than me, albeit my 25k scholarship. She was just given like pure grant money. Bothers me quite a bit...but it's just a fact of the icky financial aid process.

EFC is pretty retarded, and really screws you if you're upper middle class. Like someone in my class's dilemma is figuring out how she's going to pay for her Harvard education, because they have told her, hey, we think your parents can pay 40k a year. Um, just like start eating peanut butter sandwiches for the next forty years mom and dad, and never vacation, ever again!

I sort of laughed a little when someone told me their efc was like 70k. Didn't think it could go that high...

[edit]
College application during my school...it's when my senior class gets racist and a tad bit angry about impoverished people. "Aw, why aren't my parent's a burden on society? I'd totally get into [insert name of ivy]."

As of now I'm just keeping my fingers crossed that I get into the schools I really want to go to, and I'll just deal with the finances later. (I'll probably be paying off the loans until I'm 65...)

Updated On: 3/19/07 at 08:25 PM

#8

re: $99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

HumanTorch, I wasn't saying that scholarships should be handed out to just anyone who needs to take loans out for college or sailed through high school. I meant that it's unfortunate that in many cases, financial need isn't taken into account. Other than that, of course there's loans and other ways to get money for school. Scholarships and student loans are completely different things. People who have excelled in school and sports should be given scholarships based on merit. That's their purpose, but I was just trying to make the point that financial need isn't a factor in a lot of general scholarships. Just my two cents on the issue. Sorry if it came out wrong.

Edit: Good luck with your applications, Marlene. I'll join you on the side of the road in your carboard box.

Updated On: 3/19/07 at 09:45 PM

#9

re: $99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

i must beg to differ... most scholarships that i've seen DO take in to account financial need, especially national ones... you just have to look for them
#10

re: $99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

Amen. I think the majority of the scholarships I've looked into require some sort of racial or financial quota. It's rather annoying. I love how "financial need" isn't actually spelled out, and upon asking my in house college counselor, she asked how much I paid for school lunch. Basically I was denied. It's frustrating because I'm going to have to take out a loan either way.

We've unanimously decided that the ideal college candidates are first generation Americans, or better yet those who have recently immigrated (usually by means of perilous journey, [i.e. raft & attack dogs]), whose parents make nothing (on paper that is...), who dedicate all their free time to building and bettering their community.

Yes!, the college process turns you into a cynical being. Yeaaah, LOANS. My new best friend. Unless I magically come into contact with a benefactor to my education...

I'm not saying that they are not out there, there are some scholarships based solely on merit, but frankly when they start finalizing the recipients, even if you made it past the few preliminary rounds, it's seems as if the race and socio-economic card is commonly played.
#11

re: $99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

A calculated EFC is almost always approximately 1/3 of your parents income and it's not just based on current income. There is an assumption that families will save to help pay for their kids' college education. When families don't save, that's when it becomes a problem.

Scholarships can have different qualifications. Some require financial need, some are based strictly on merit, and some have some combination of the two.
#12

re: $99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

There are scholarships available (usually from individual schools) based solely on financial need. There are also some based solely on merit. A lot are based on a combination of both.

EFCs are notoriously high and barely anyone can afford theirs, but unfortunately it's something almost all of us have to deal with. Paying loans straight out of college is going to be something a HUGE portion of our generation is going to have to learn to do.

I'm just going to make a broad request that we all be a little more sensitive when talking about this stuff. Some of these comments could be really hurtful to some of the readers here who might come from different backgrounds than your own. I'm not pointing fingers at anyone, I just don't want anyone to feel put down or that they've been handed things they don't deserve.
"grace, you're stuffed in a box getting rid of ass plaque. let's face it, this evening is a bust."
#13

re: $99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

My EFC is almost $70,000, but my parents won't pay for any of my tuition. But every scholarship still looks at that figure. It's frusterating because I have outstanding achievements, but no scholarship committee will even look at them.

Scholarships should be reserved for achievements, not given to someone just because their parents don't make a lot of money - that's what loans are for. By taking into account the student's financial need, you are insulting those who have worked hard to be competent students.
#14

re: $99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

I was given the largest merit scholarship amount my top school offers (15,000 for this particular school) but when the estimated living costs clock in at 40,000 it's still a lot of money. To make matters worse, my parents are willing to pay for my education, but do not want me taking out student loans. (they say, and rightly so, that you should not walk out of college being tens of thousands of dollars in debt). So, I have to find a school that is affordable enough. Now granted I may just go to another school that is less expensive and so forth, but it's still quite discouraging to know that obviousl this school saw something fitting for me, and I saw something fitting with it and now I can't go there.
#15

re: $99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

The scholarships given in regard to merit are usually MUCH MUCH larger than those that are ONLY considering financial need (which are usually only around $1000-$3000).

Most of the financial aid that goes to kids with a smaller EFC is in the form of loans. Huge huge loans.
"grace, you're stuffed in a box getting rid of ass plaque. let's face it, this evening is a bust."
#16

re: $99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

Becky, you're assuming that students who do have financial need have not worked hard "to be competent students". That's pretty insulting, not to mention inaccurate. There are different types of scholarships, as I and sporti have both mentioned, which take into account different aspects of a student's situation. Most which are based solely on merit are larger than those based solely on financial need. While it's unfortunate that your parents have made the decision not to support you financially, the fact remains that they COULD pay if they wanted to. If scholarship awards were based on whose parents didn't want to pay, then honestly, what parents WOULD want to pay?! Financial need is based on actual need, not on whether some irresponsible parents decide not to fund their child's education. I don't receive any need-based aid but your comment offended me, and I can imagine how those who post here who DO have financial need must have felt reading it.
#17

re: $99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

The issue of parents paying is certainly a challenge. Legally, they owe the child nothing if the child is no longer a minor. To tell a child just because your parents won't pay for college means you should not be eligible for any financial scholarships is absurd. My parents are willing to help me pay for college and I thank them for that, but I have seen terrible circumstances with extended family members where their father suddenly quit paying for the college (after promising to) despite no real financial situation that could prevent him from doing so. To tell these students "tough luck" is absurd.

The real question is, why can't college be more affordable?
#18

re: $99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

The reality is, though, that no one is telling them 'tough luck'. What students in that situation face, along with thousands of others whose families can't afford to pay for expensive colleges, is that student loans will have to be taken out, and that they may have to rethink where they go to college. It's a financial reality that not everyone can afford an expensive college. No one is entitled, just as no one is entitled to drive an expensive car. The issue about whether college should be a right is another issue altogether but in the meantime, people have to be realistic about what they, or their families, can afford to pay and about how much they are willing to borrow to pay for it. There are thousands of kids who work to pay for their education, or they go to Community College for a couple of years then transfer in order to save some money. Is it easy? No, but it IS do-able, and it's what many kids have to do in order to get a college education.

Updated On: 3/20/07 at 01:07 PM

#19

re: $99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

Becky -- I absolutely do not understand why you think that students should not be offered scholarships based on financial need. While I understand that you feel that your acheivements are maybe being downplayed by the fact that you can't apply to any scholarships (which isn't true, might I add, since there are TONS of merit/essay-based scholarships), some people (including myself) simply do not have any resources (whether offered or unoffered by parents) to afford college. I sincerely feel badly for you (in terms of the fact that your parents won't pay for your college), but I, too, think that it's (at least) mildly insulting that you seem to think that students who are in a state of financial need are incompetent.

Financial need is the basis of many scholarships, but the majority also take academic achievement into consideration. Plus, I'm sure you could write a letter explaining your circumstances and enclose it in your scholarship applications. I imagine that it WOULD be quite frustrating to be in need of money but not have it recognized. I suppose you might just have to force people to recognize it! =P

Either way, good luck on getting the money you need, and I apologize if I have insulted anybody with my horror at the girl's $99,999 EFC.
#20

re: $99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

that is obscene. wow.
that is really infortunate too, because people who really need those scholarships won't be able to have them because of people who have all the money in the world but are stingy. that definitely doesn't go for everyone; however, i know of situations when that happens and it just sucks!
hear my song; it was made for the time when you don't know where to go, listen to the song that i sing, you'll be fine..
#21

re: $99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

lovelyspotlight... i think the point is that if a person is competing with one other individual who is highly qualified, and his parents have some (or all) of the money necessary to eliminate them from financial need status, what makes the person with financial need so deserving of this money if he isn't the most qualified... college isn't for everybody and elite colleges aren't for everybody, and if you haven't studied hard enough to qualify academically, why feel entitled to it just because you don't have enough money?
#22

re: $99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

I completely see/understand the point you're making.

I guess I just read Becky's "By taking into account the student's financial need, you are insulting those who have worked hard to be competent students." as an indirect way of saying that those who have financial need could not possibly have worked hard to be competent students. I also tend to read too much into things and sometimes (when it comes to academics, which I HAVE worked hard for, although I tend to believe I was competent to begin with) get a tiny bit offended a little easily.

Oh well. Sorry.

Also, some people aren't blessed with an inherent knack for academics. Some people work as hard as they can and don't even get as far, academically, as the slacker AP student. These people deserve a chance at a scholarship, even though they may not have THE most qualified academic record. That's where recommendation letters (required for some scholarships and, of course, colleges) come in.

Honestly, there seems to really be no concrete method for determining whether or not one deserves/needs financial aid. I guess scholarship corporations just do the best they can in order to be as fair as possible to as many people as possible.

=/
#23

re: $99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

I didn't mean to imply that people with finanical need are incompetant, sorry if it came off that way. I just think that an award whose name implies merit, should be based on merit. Whether or not your parents make a lot of money should not matter. I do think that there should be help for those whose parents cannot afford college - but it should not be scholarships - it should be government grants and loans.
#24

re: $99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

AHHHHHH! FAFSA don't say that word! It's EEEEVIL! sorry

The greatest thing you'll ever learn is just to love and be loved in return

Updated On: 3/21/07 at 12:52 PM

#25

re: $99,999 EFC (FAFSA)?!

Ahh, okay. I gotcha, Becky. =]

Also, for your scholarship needs, have you looked on fastweb.com, schoolsoup.com, and scholarships.com? They're, for the most part, for around $1,000-$5,000 each, but they can add up! Best of luck getting money for college!! (It isn't proving too incredibly easy for me or for anybody I've talked to...)

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $60
Hot Show
Tickets From $71