Just watched it--and cried.
The Kurt/gay storyline is carrying the show at this point: It's pitch-perfect, avoids cliche and is impeccably played.
And the musical numbers are always well done--even when Lea Michele is singing her inner monologue or the "audition" scenes have sophisticated lighting effects.
So it's just the other storylines--which are supposed to be outlandish--where the show is struggling to find its comic vision. The Strangers With Candy approach to the school stories doesn't really gel with the soap opera elements.
But if they can bring the relationship dramas up to the level of the musical numbers and the coming-out story, it could be a great, great show. THIS. All of it. haha
I loooove the show and am getting so into it, but it's definitely the case that the strong parts are REALLY super strong and the weak parts are pretty darn weak.
The music numbers, Kurt's storyline, and some of the general writing (one liners, certain comedic moments, etc) are basically what's making the show amazing right now. But the whole double pregnancy thing is just so.. unnecessary. I'm FINE with things not always being totally believable, but they also have to be engaging. And that storyline is one I'm consistently bored with. And it seems like someone is always leaving glee and then returning, leaving and then returning. There's always the same drama with that. So they just need to work out those story lines.
It certainly isn't making the show unenjoyable- I'm getting totally obsessed with it! And the really fantastic parts are more common than the weaker parts anyway. But if they COULD bring those other story lines up to the same level as the brilliantly written stuff, it would be so perfect!
I don't need a life that's normal. That's way too far away. But something next to normal would be okay. Something next to normal is what I'd like to try. Close enough to normal to get by.
Updated On: 9/25/09 at 11:03 PM