Give That Girl An Oscar! Game- Page 2

[touchmeinthemorning]

Posted: 11/23/05 at 11:21am

Myrna Loy 14
Marilyn Monroe 8
Mae West 9 -
Rita Hayworth 12
Tallulah Bankhead 11
Jeanette MacDonald 11
Alice Faye 9
Ann Miller 9
Cyd Charisse 11 +
Jean Harlow 9
Hedy Lamarr 12
June Allyson 6
Lena Horne 10
Betty Hutton 9

For Silk Stocking's being forgotten about at Oscar time.

[lildogs]

Posted: 11/23/05 at 12:26pm

Myrna Loy 14
Marilyn Monroe 8
Mae West 9
Rita Hayworth 12
Tallulah Bankhead 11
Jeanette MacDonald 11
Alice Faye 9
Ann Miller 9
Cyd Charisse 11
Jean Harlow 10 +
Hedy Lamarr 12
June Allyson 5 -
Lena Horne 10
Betty Hutton 9

[touchmeinthemorning]

Posted: 11/23/05 at 12:50pm

Myrna Loy 14
Marilyn Monroe 8
Mae West 9
Rita Hayworth 12
Tallulah Bankhead 11
Jeanette MacDonald 11
Alice Faye 9
Ann Miller 9
Cyd Charisse 11
Jean Harlow 10
Hedy Lamarr 13 +
June Allyson 4 -
Lena Horne 10
Betty Hutton 9

[BrendanStryker]

Posted: 11/23/05 at 1:16pm

These games give me excess acid, and I swore I'd never do another after the director's game; but I just cannot sit idly by, and allow Cyd Charisse(???) and Lena Horne (???)to have more votes than Alice Faye!!!

Myrna Loy 14
Marilyn Monroe 8
Mae West 9
Rita Hayworth 12
Tallulah Bankhead 11
Jeanette MacDonald 11
Alice Faye 10 +
Ann Miller 9
Cyd Charisse 11
Jean Harlow 10
Hedy Lamarr 13
June Allyson 4
Lena Horne 9 -
Betty Hutton 9

[GovernorSlaton]

Posted: 11/23/05 at 4:10pm

Myrna Loy 14
Marilyn Monroe 8
Mae West 9
Rita Hayworth 12
Tallulah Bankhead 11
Jeanette MacDonald 12 +
Alice Faye 10
Ann Miller 9
Cyd Charisse 10 -
Jean Harlow 10
Hedy Lamarr 13
June Allyson 4
Lena Horne 9
Betty Hutton 9

[MyMeredithMonster]

Posted: 11/23/05 at 4:25pm

Myrna Loy 14
Marilyn Monroe 9 +
Mae West 9
Rita Hayworth 12
Tallulah Bankhead 11
Jeanette MacDonald 12
Alice Faye 10
Ann Miller 9
Cyd Charisse 10
Jean Harlow 10
Hedy Lamarr 13
June Allyson 3 -
Lena Horne 9
Betty Hutton 9

[Princeton78]

Posted: 11/23/05 at 5:04pm

Myrna Loy 14
Marilyn Monroe 9
Mae West 9
Rita Hayworth 12
Tallulah Bankhead 10 -
Jeanette MacDonald 12
Alice Faye 10
Ann Miller 9
Cyd Charisse 10
Jean Harlow 10
Hedy Lamarr 14
June Allyson 3
Lena Horne 9
Betty Hutton 9

[lildogs]

Posted: 11/25/05 at 9:11am

Myrna Loy 14
Marilyn Monroe 10 +
Mae West 9
Rita Hayworth 12
Tallulah Bankhead 10
Jeanette MacDonald 12
Alice Faye 10
Ann Miller 9
Cyd Charisse 10
Jean Harlow 10
Hedy Lamarr 14
June Allyson 2 -
Lena Horne 9
Betty Hutton 9

[melissa errico fan]

Posted: 11/25/05 at 9:15am

Myrna Loy 14
Marilyn Monroe 10
Mae West 9
Rita Hayworth 12
Tallulah Bankhead 11 (+)
Jeanette MacDonald 12
Alice Faye 10
Ann Miller 9
Cyd Charisse 10
Jean Harlow 10
Hedy Lamarr 13 (-)
June Allyson 2
Lena Horne 9
Betty Hutton 9

[lildogs]

Posted: 11/25/05 at 10:03am

Myrna Loy 14
Marilyn Monroe 10
Mae West 10 +
Rita Hayworth 12
Tallulah Bankhead 11
Jeanette MacDonald 12
Alice Faye 10
Ann Miller 9
Cyd Charisse 10
Jean Harlow 10
Hedy Lamarr 13
June Allyson 1 -
Lena Horne 9
Betty Hutton 9

[touchmeinthemorning]

Posted: 11/29/05 at 12:03pm

Myrna Loy 14
Marilyn Monroe 10
Mae West 10
Rita Hayworth 12
Tallulah Bankhead 11
Jeanette MacDonald 12
Alice Faye 10
Ann Miller 9
Cyd Charisse 10
Jean Harlow 10
Hedy Lamarr 14 +
June Allyson 0 -
Lena Horne 9
Betty Hutton 9

[Mamie]

Posted: 11/29/05 at 12:34pm

Myrna Loy 15 +
Marilyn Monroe 10
Mae West 9 -
Rita Hayworth 12
Tallulah Bankhead 11
Jeanette MacDonald 12
Alice Faye 10
Ann Miller 9
Cyd Charisse 10
Jean Harlow 10
Hedy Lamarr 14
June Allyson 0
Lena Horne 9
Betty Hutton 9

Updated On: 11/29/05 at 12:34 PM

[lildogs]

Posted: 11/29/05 at 12:36pm

Myrna Loy 16 +
Marilyn Monroe 10
Mae West 9
Rita Hayworth 12
Tallulah Bankhead 11
Jeanette MacDonald 12
Alice Faye 10
Ann Miller 9
Cyd Charisse 10
Jean Harlow 10
Hedy Lamarr 13 -
Lena Horne 9
Betty Hutton 9

[melissa errico fan]

Posted: 11/29/05 at 1:02pm

Myrna Loy 16
Marilyn Monroe 10
Mae West 9
Rita Hayworth 12
Tallulah Bankhead 11
Jeanette MacDonald 12
Alice Faye 10
Ann Miller 10 (+)
Cyd Charisse 10
Jean Harlow 10
Hedy Lamarr 13
Lena Horne 8 (-)
Betty Hutton 9

[NCGuy]

Posted: 11/29/05 at 1:04pm

Myrna Loy 16
Marilyn Monroe 10
Mae West 10 (+)
Rita Hayworth 12
Tallulah Bankhead 11
Jeanette MacDonald 12
Alice Faye 10
Ann Miller 10
Cyd Charisse 10
Jean Harlow 10
Hedy Lamarr 12 (-)
Lena Horne 8
Betty Hutton 9

[lildogs]

Posted: 11/29/05 at 1:10pm

Myrna Loy 16
Marilyn Monroe 10
Mae West 10
Rita Hayworth 12
Tallulah Bankhead 11
Jeanette MacDonald 12
Alice Faye 10
Ann Miller 10
Cyd Charisse 10
Jean Harlow 11 (+)
Hedy Lamarr 11 (-)
Lena Horne 8
Betty Hutton 9

[BrendanStryker]

Posted: 11/29/05 at 1:13pm

Myrna Loy 16
Marilyn Monroe 10
Mae West 10
Rita Hayworth 12
Tallulah Bankhead 11
Jeanette MacDonald 12
Alice Faye 11 +
Ann Miller 10
Cyd Charisse 9-
Jean Harlow 11
Hedy Lamarr 11
Lena Horne 8
Betty Hutton 9

[touchmeinthemorning]

Posted: 11/29/05 at 3:55pm

Myrna Loy 16
Marilyn Monroe 10
Mae West 9 -
Rita Hayworth 12
Tallulah Bankhead 11
Jeanette MacDonald 13 +
Alice Faye 11
Ann Miller 10
Cyd Charisse 9
Jean Harlow 11
Hedy Lamarr 11
Lena Horne 8
Betty Hutton 9

[lildogs]

Posted: 11/29/05 at 4:12pm

Myrna Loy 16
Marilyn Monroe 10
Mae West 9
Rita Hayworth 12
Tallulah Bankhead 11
Jeanette MacDonald 14 +
Alice Faye 11
Ann Miller 10
Cyd Charisse 9
Jean Harlow 11
Hedy Lamarr 10 -
Lena Horne 8
Betty Hutton 9

[NCGuy]

Posted: 11/29/05 at 4:39pm

Myrna Loy 18 +
Marilyn Monroe 10
Mae West 9
Rita Hayworth 12
Tallulah Bankhead 11
Jeanette MacDonald 14
Alice Faye 11
Ann Miller 10
Cyd Charisse 9
Jean Harlow 10
Hedy Lamarr 10
Lena Horne 7 -
Betty Hutton 9

Lildogs, I don’t mean to overthink this game, but are we supposed to have specific performances in mind when voting?

I know this is all subjective, but I'm having trouble imagining what films half of these actresses (as wonderful as they all were) would have been nominated for.

[touchmeinthemorning]

Posted: 11/29/05 at 4:42pm

Myrna Loy 18
Marilyn Monroe 10
Mae West 9
Rita Hayworth 12
Tallulah Bankhead 11
Jeanette MacDonald 14
Alice Faye 11
Ann Miller 10
Cyd Charisse 9
Jean Harlow 10
Hedy Lamarr 11 +
Lena Horne 6 -
Betty Hutton 9

[lildogs]

Posted: 11/29/05 at 4:44pm

Myrna Loy 18
Marilyn Monroe 10
Mae West 9
Rita Hayworth 12
Tallulah Bankhead 11
Jeanette MacDonald 14
Alice Faye 11
Ann Miller 9 -
Cyd Charisse 9
Jean Harlow 11 +
Hedy Lamarr 10
Lena Horne 7
Betty Hutton 9


You MIGHT be overthinking a bit, but I could add titles to make it more interesting, but who's to say Myrna is better in The Best Years of Our Lives than she was in The Thin Man? Or Jean Harlow in Dinner at Eight over Red Dust? Or Rita in Gilda or The Lady From Shanghai? I'll pick just one if you think it'll make the game more interesting, but they will be MY choices...

[Mamie]

Posted: 11/29/05 at 4:57pm

Myrna Loy 19 +
Marilyn Monroe 10
Mae West 9
Rita Hayworth 12
Tallulah Bankhead 11
Jeanette MacDonald 13 -
Alice Faye 11
Ann Miller 9
Cyd Charisse 9
Jean Harlow 11
Hedy Lamarr 10
Lena Horne 7
Betty Hutton 9

[NCGuy]

Posted: 11/29/05 at 5:11pm

Myrna Loy 19
Marilyn Monroe 10
Mae West 9
Rita Hayworth 12
Tallulah Bankhead 11
Jeanette MacDonald 13
Alice Faye 11
Ann Miller 9
Cyd Charisse 9
Jean Harlow 12 +
Hedy Lamarr 9 -
Lena Horne 7
Betty Hutton 9

Oh, I didn’t mean for you to specify performances…I guess I’m just thinking of some of these women as great stars or great screen presences, not necessarily great, award-worthy actresses (but again, that’s just my opinion and I realize this is all subjective…each actress has her fans). Sorry…didn’t mean to make it more complicated…was just curious.

[lildogs]

Posted: 11/29/05 at 5:25pm

If you think of alot of nominated actresses...I think you'll find just as many huhs? to the ones who made it as the ones who didn't.

Examples:

Ali McGraw-Love Story
Elizabeth Taylor-Butterfield 8 or Raintree County
Lana Turner-Peyton Place
Doris Day-Pillow Talk
Ava Gardner-Mogambo
Jennifer Jones-Duel in the Sun
Norma Shearer-Romeo and Juliet

Yes, I know SOME of these ladies did give great performances, just not any of these....