I need some opinions

so once again I'm having an extremely difficult time deciding between doing two shows. I'm choosing between Footloose and Into the Woods. I had originally planned to do both, but it was just changed so that they perform on the same weekend. Footloose is one of my dream shows and I'm not sure that I'll get another opportunity to do it. But my younger sister is doing Into the Woods and it will be her first musical ever and I want to be a part of that. Also the director for Into the Woods is also doing Newsies later in the year and I want to make sure that she will be able to do it well. Thoughts?