Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!
#1

Lucy and Jesse

Lee Remick or Blythe Danner?

Edit by me to fix the title.

" ...the happiness in the tune convinces me that I'm not afraid."

Updated On: 3/16/05 at 09:41 PM

#2

re: Jesse's a lassie you pat on the head...

that's a tough one Glebb.....I saw Blythe Danner do it twice...so I'd have to go with her...but I did love Lee Remick.
"To be yourself in a world that is constantly trying to make you something else is the greatest accomplishment. Ralph Waldo Emerson
#3

re: Jesse's a lassie you pat on the head...

With no recording or video of Blythe Danner, it really limits the number of people who can compare them. I wish I could say I could, but I can't.
#4

re: Jesse's a lassie you pat on the head...

No contest: Alexis Smith.

The other are just play-acting.

And correction: LUCY's a lassie you pat on the head; Jessie is classy, but virtually dead.
#7

re: Jesse's a lassie you pat on the head...

You were too busy playing Little League, right PalJoey? re: Jesse's a lassie you pat on the head...
"Two drifters off to see the world. There's such a lot of world to see. . ."
#8

If Lucy and Jessie could only combine...

The recorded Phyllis's, in order of performance (on disc):

Alexis Smith
















Dee Hoty
Lee Remick

If Lucy and Jessie could only combine...

Updated On: 3/16/05 at 09:58 PM

#9

re: Jesse's a lassie you pat on the head...

Sadly there is nothing left for me to do but turn in my showqueen card.
Way too many mistakes. re: Jesse's a lassie you pat on the head...
" ...the happiness in the tune convinces me that I'm not afraid."
#10

If Lucy and Jessie could only combine...

I gave up Little League to worship Stephen Sondheim. I memorized this one and performed it every Saturday afternoon in left field.

Here's a little story that should make you cry,
About two unhappy dames.
Let us call them Lucy "X" and Jessie "Y"
(Which are not their real names).

Now Lucy has the purity
Along with the unsurety
That comes with being only twenty-one.
Jessie has maturity
And plenty of security.
Whatever you can do with them she's done!

Given their advantages,
You may ask why
The two ladies have such grief.
This is my belief...
In brief:

Lucy is juicy
But terribly drab.
Jessie is dressy
But cold as a slab.
Lucy wants to be dressy.
Jessie wants to be juicy.
Lucy wants to be Jessie
And Jessie Lucy.

You see,
Jessie is racy
But hard as a rock.
Lucy is lacy
But dull as a smock.
Jessie wants to be lacy,
Lucy wants to be Jessie.
That's the sorrowful précis.
(It's very messy.)

Poor sad souls,
Itching to be switching roles.
Lucy wants to do what Jessie does,
Jessie wants to be what Lucy was.

Lucy's a lassie
You pat on the head.
Jessie is classy
But virtually dead.
Lucy wants to be classy.
Jessie wants to be Lassie.
If Lucy and Jessie could only combine,
I could tell you someone
Who would finally feel just fine!
#11

Tell them that they oughta get together quick...

'Cause getting it together is the whole....TRICK! YEAH!

What did you substitute for the bright red dress? That song cannot be performed without the bright red dress.
#12

If Lucy and Jessie could only combine...

I think EVERYONE was outdone by Diana Rigg performing "Ah, But Underneath" in the same spot in the London production.


A Note of Trivia: "The Story of Lucy and Jessie" replaced a number called "Uptown Downtown." In that number, the dancers were going to dance in opposite directions at the same time--to demonstrate the confusion Phyllis was going through while she performed--but it proved a little too hard for Michael Bennett to choreograph properly.
"I say YOU'RE the CUTEST one. No, I say YOU'RE the CUTEST One. And we go on like that from dawn to three."
#13

If Lucy and Jessie could only combine...

I actually prefer Ah, But Underneath to both Lucy and Jessie and Uptown Downtown.

"If his idea of ecstasy's to see what he expects to see: Well, ignorance is bliss, but think of what he'll miss..."
#14

If Lucy and Jessie could only combine...

First of all, Glebb, your showqueen card is PLATINUM and it never expires. After all, I could never have put that red dress on and done the choreography. You could have--and you would have looked fabulous. Those who can, do. The rest of us (like me) memorize lyrics.

And yes, Guv and M-E, Ah, but Underneath has brilliant lyrics, but what Sondheim song doesn't? Lucy/Jessie had the post-modern pastiche quality that Losing My Mind, Buddy's Blues and Live/Laugh/Love had, all of which contributed to making the end of that show a total mind-f*ck. They were Sondheimian versions of the kinds of songs performers like that did in shows like that, yet they summed up the core psychological problem of each character with devastatingly incisive irony. Ah, but Underneath misses out on those multiple levels and operates on a single level. Underneath that song, there isn't much.

Plus, Alexis Smith was so incredible looking slinking around in that red dress, and the lyrics were a tongue-twister.
#15

If Lucy and Jessie could only combine...

Yep, Gov.

For the life of me, I COULD NEVER FIGURE OUT why the Roundabout Revivial went back to "Lucy and Jessie" AFTER "Ah, But Underneath" was such a SENSATION in London.

Anyone have any insight on that?
"I say YOU'RE the CUTEST one. No, I say YOU'RE the CUTEST One. And we go on like that from dawn to three."
#17

If Lucy and Jessie could only combine...

Thanks for your vote of confidence PJ! :)
Your post was very interesting and helped me with Putting It Together. Mom loved Alexis and she loved Follies.
" ...the happiness in the tune convinces me that I'm not afraid."
#23

If Lucy and Jessie could only combine...

i'd refer those interested in this thread to the thread FOLLIES AT PAPER MILL on the main board. Much similar discussion.

For me, i'd like to see/hear Dee Hoty add "Lucy/Jessie" to her Phyllis repertoire (because she did "Underneath" for Paper Mill).

And just another bit of trivia---it took a while out of town for "Losing My Mind" to leave Phyllis' song list and join Sally's. Now how 'bout THEM apples? can you imagine?!?!?
Will: They don't give out awards for helping people be gay... unless you count the Tonys. "I guarantee that we'll have tough times. I guarantee that at some point one or both of us will want to get out. But I also guarantee that if I don't ask you to be mine, I'll regret it for the rest of my life..."
#24

If Lucy and Jessie could only combine...

It is perfectly acceptable for baby show queens to perform on a sports field sans costume as long as it is the original choreography. Spiked shoes only add to the challenge. I was once sent off a football field because it was thought that my FLAWLESS rendition of "Turkey Lurkey Time" was upsetting the other team. Actually, it was MY team gunning for me after the match as I recall...

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $70
Hot Show
Tickets From $77
Hot Show
Tickets From $106
Hot Show
Tickets From $133