Joined: 12/31/69
I've always loved the Double Stuff Oreos. I assumed everybody else did too.
Then my sister said she liked the original ones better.
So, discuss.
I prefer original. The amount of cream is more proportionate to the cookies; double stuff is just too much.
Double-stuff.
Also, I love vanilla pudding with crushed oreos on top.
Broadway Legend Joined: 7/18/03
Your sister is flat out wrong.
After double stuff, single stuff are a dry ----, and you can fill in the blanks.
Double Stuff. If I'm gonna clog my arteries with lard, I want those babies CLOGGED!
Broadway Legend Joined: 12/14/05
i prefer the holiday variety with the colored cream. They have more cream than the regular, but not as much as the double stuff. It's a nice balance.
Double Stuff are juff too muff.
oreo eaters are murderers!
killers who deserve nothing less summary executions for the violent death they force upon others!
die oreo eaters!
Broadway Legend Joined: 12/31/69
OK, so I'm going to hell.
I just ate a pile of double stuff oreos.
They were so worth every second I'm going to spend in hell for murdering them.
I prefer an original on top of a Double stuff
I LOVE the ones that come out during the holidays that are covered in white chocolate. They are the only cookie I eat.
second hand oreos kill!
that's not my problem papa. Don't stand so close to people who are eating them.
Me too, Taz- the white fudge covered ones are amazing!!
I love the Double Stuf.
Oreos are going to be the death of me.

Peanut Butter Double Stuff!
Broadway Legend Joined: 1/19/08
I pull all mine apart and eat the cream-attached sides as reconstructed Oreos. As in... half my regulars are like Double Stuf and half my Double Stuf are like Quadruple Stuf. However, it's always too much or too little cream. I think I'm going to start making them with half original and half Double Stuf!
Broadway Legend Joined: 9/29/04
Double Stuf all the way. Now that I've experienced the magic of a Double Stuf OREO, the regular ones just don't seem like enough.
God bless America.
When I was young I used to always make quadruple stuffed. Now double is fine. I also REALLY like the mint ones. I try to never buy them, but there are times.....
Broadway Legend Joined: 12/14/05
I'm all about the double stuffed.
Sometimes I carefully remove the cookie off one side of two doubles, then press the two cookies that have the cream together so it is quadruple stuffed. Oh yeah. It's a heart attack waiting to happen. Did I mention I have a sweet tooth?
Thankfully I never let myself buy oreos so it is only once in a very blue moon that I get to do this.
Videos