Basically, I think this motivator is so much bullcrap. I've been thinking a lot this week about the illusions we are trained to have from an early age about the decisions we arrive at. And how in a hyper-mediated culture, many of us like to think that we're free and independent thinkers and that we have SO much control over SO many aspects of our lives.
And that's crap.
I've been thinking about this since seeing the reunion performance of post-punk pioneers Gang of Four the other night. And what they sang about captures what I've been feeling so perfectly, which is basically the antithesis of this motivator.
Greil Marcus, one of the greatest rock writers ever, wrote a great essay about Gang of Four in 1990. Which I excerpt here.
"There was something on the Gang of Four's collective mind, picked up from books, painting (Manet's especially), movies (notably Jean-Luc Godard's Numero Deux), not-so-fast R&B (George Clinton's Parliament-Funkadelic), and Leeds street politics (marches against the neo Nazi National Front party that ended with police violence; violent attacks by Front goons on pubs frequented by the likes of the band and their pals the Mekons and Delta 5).
"What was on their mind was the notion that everyday life-wage labor, official propaganda, the commodity system, but also the way you bought a shirt, how you made love, the feeling you had as you watched the nightly news or turned away from it-was not 'natural,' but the product of an invisible hand. It was an interested construction, someone else's project, a rulers' project. Some of the rulers were dead, some were living, but all held power. 'The attitudes and beliefs that people take as being natural,' [singer John] King said early on, 'have been inherited through the social structure they're brought up in. An example is the man who believes that women are by definition more suited to working in the home than to making decisions. The belief in the natural puts all this outside the realm of debate - and unless you have an awareness of your ideas as political manifestations, you won't believe you can change them."
"If you're not aware of the processes and thoughts by which you arrive at a statement about a situation", Gill said of the bands songs, "If you're not aware of that, you probably can't sufficiently analyse the situation".
more
Twitter @NamoInExile
Instagram none
Updated On: 5/19/05 at 11:39 AM