I agree Erik, that the closest I got to "scared" was in the beginning, and those moments of silent blackness were genuinely tense and spooky. The moment I nearly called "safety" was **SPOILERS** the waterboarding because between all the forced screaming and the water and the sack over my face I actually began to feel panicky and really couldn't breathe. If it had gone on another 20 seconds, I wouldn't have made it. It wasn't scary, but it was intensely visceral, and for me that was totally a valid part of the experience.
The tampon scene and the vomit/key scene had a kind of cheesy fun to them. I wasn't legitimately grossed out, but I do remember laughing and wincing before I plunged my hand into the toilet. The whole thing had an adrenaliney feel once it got going, and for me it was, altogether, totally worth it, especially when you consider the alternatives are typically haunted hayrides with wannabe actors in rubber masks yelling "boo."
I'm not easily scared, so I'm always on the lookout for things that might actually get me. Eastern Penitentiary has been on my radar the past few years, but I just haven't made it. I really, really, really want to go this year.
CHURCH DOOR TOUCAN GAY MARKETING PUPPIES MUSICAL THEATER STAPLES PERIOD OIL BITCHY SNARK HOLES