qolbinau said: "I still would like to hear from someone at BWW about this. For those that didn't see the topic, it invited discussion about whether there were challenges in the gay community that made it difficult for us to achieve long-term relationships, and invited people to potentially provide suggestions of how we might overcome this. Seems like a completely legitimate conversation topic on an off-topic board to me.
"
I AM NOT A MOD, NOR AM I AUTHORIZED TO SPEAK FOR BWW.COM IN ANY WAY.
But I have been a member of a True Crime board for almost 20 years and have seen these issues ebb and flow there as well as here. A few thoughts:
1. When a moderator explains a deletion, it only begins an even longer conversation that serves to take up time the mod may not have.
2. Explaining a deletion may only serve to reemphasize the original violation of the TOS. E.g., if I call you a c*** and my post is deleted, how does the mod explain the deletion of the post without basically repeating my slur? Even just explaining that a personal slur was deleted, without being specific, serves the purpose of inviting each of us to imagine the worst possible disparagement.
3. Posts that quote offending posts are often deleted; mods don't necessarily have time to remove the offending quote and if they did, the remaining post might no longer make sense..
4. Unoffensive posts are often deleted along with offensive ones because the benign posts lose their meaning when the context is changed.
5. Re 3 and 4: To do otherwise would require a mod to literally rewrite an entire thread, post by post, adding context to preserve the meaning of each comment after the deletions were gone.
6. An entire thread may be deleted when it becomes obvious that the subject matter is so incendiary that we posters just can't discuss it civilly. This is not to say the threat-starter is to blame; but it doesn't hurt to remember that my post may have been deleted because of the responses that came after, not because I did anything wrong in the first place. (Here again, explaining why is an invitation to start the whole conversation over.)
Obviously, the moderating is a little tighter right now and Rob has graciously explained why. My personal hope is that the reins will be relaxed a little after a while, but ultimately that isn't my call. I do think we should all remember that moderating an internet forum is an art not a science. A period of adjustment is to be expected.
Updated On: 4/15/16 at 08:40 PM