I don't think Criterion has the cache that they used to have. Not because they've gone downhill, but because the studios actually release their own remastered, in-depth, special edition titles now.
Criterion used to be a leader in fancy home entertainment releases, but that was back when laser discs were the preferred format for film buffs.
They could pick and choose what they would release. Not so, anymore.
Criterion still means "special edition" to me today (although, some of their DVD releases have been pretty bare-bones).
But they don't get as many titles as they used to for "gussying up" because the studios are doing the job themselves.
So... It's not an award-worthy big deal to say "the Criterion Edition of blah-blah"...
To me, it just hopefully means it's a Special Edition of blah-blah.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22