I've been a wimp my whole life, I guess. "Are You Afraid of the Dark?" scared the CRAP out of me. I saw one episode and made a point never to watch another, again. "Legends of the Hidden Temple" kinda spooked me a little too... I had nightmares about those guys who'd grab contestants, while they were looking for the silver monkey at the end. Loved the show, but I'd jump a foot, whenever that happened.
Pinky: I don't have digital cable.

I don't know if Nick Arcade would still hold my interest the way it did at age 6, though. XD
Remember Family Double Dare? Figure it Out? Pete and Pete? The Secret World of Alex Mac (was that the name)?
All That was like SNL for kids.