Saw this tonight. I think my experience was partly tainted by being very tired, and having a lot of rude audience members talking through it around me. But in general, I had kind of mixed feelings about it. Shaina Taub is a great composer, but I think her lyrics for this project were kind of middling - a lot of it tended to be kind of trite or 2 dimensional. I think if you're going to replace sections of Shakespearean text with your own words, they had better be good. I know it's been done several times, but the only other time I've seen it done was with Love's Labour's Lost. I enjoyed LLL more than this because the play has less substance than As You Like It, so the songs were just goofy and fun, and it didn't really matter if they supported the story or not. That said, I enjoyed some numbers very much. The principal cast is excellent. I had never seen Darius de Haas before except in ensembles. I knew he was well-regarded, and now I see why. He has a pretty small part in this, but he has a lot of charisma. Rebecca Naomi Jones and Ato Blankson-Wood are both lovely and have great chemistry. I liked that they made 2 of the supporting character couples same-sex. Some clever bits of staging and direction as well.
Then there's the community. The Public has amassed an enormous ensemble, made up of amateurs of all ages, who have been recruited from various community groups around New York - apparently from predominately Black communities. In theory, it's a lovely idea. Get people involved in the arts, bring communities together, represent real people of color onstage. It's a lovely theatre outreach idea that I am fully in support of. From an artistic standpoint, however, it did make the production feel very busy and crowded, and it felt more like amateur community theatre, despite the high level of talent in the leading roles. Taub wrote a framing device that ties the community ensemble in an ultimately moving and beautiful way. But the framing device doesn't actually seem to have much to do with the play itself, so it wasn't as impactful as it could have been.
Overall, this production felt like a bit of a mess. But in many ways, I suppose it was a beautiful mess.