Having seen the show last Saturday, the biggest problem is not the cast. They make do with what they have and what they have is disappointing and flat. The show felt as if it were in its first tryout week instead of its last.
There could be all sorts of finger pointing by everybody at everybody else, but there is a basic question: what do these people have to sing about? Why should we, the audience, want to spend 2:40 with these people?
The material would make a good Jim Carrey-Nathan Lane 100 minute comedy. As it is, what we have is an episodic tale that builds not at all toward an ending.
The book is solidly unfunny as is the direction,and the score is undistinguished at first hearing. Perhaps the disc will reveal some massive subtleties, but in the theatre, it lacks flair. Were the book to be rewritten, which it would need a complete overhaul, then songs would not fit and many of them would require rewriting.
The show isn't bad, per se, but it sure as hell isn't any good either. There is no THERE there. Its time to leave it alone and move on to something else.
"If my life weren't funny, it would just be true. And that would be unacceptable."
--Carrie Fisher