May, 1991 - Tyne Daly in GYPSY. Saw it by 'default', didn't want to see it at all, and turned out to be one of the best and most memorable theater nights in my life.
1994-1995? - The tours of both 'Tommy' and 'JSC'. Both were in the mid 90s, both were part of the subscription series (could have been in the same season!) and both blew me away.
1996 - Betty Buckley in 'Sunset Boulevard'.
2017 - Donna Murphy' in 'Hello, Dolly!'