Broadway bound! My show list/post show haunt suggestions request!

Hi everyone! After weeks of reading your reviews/thoughts on the new season of shows I have finally purchased our last ticket for our first trip to NYC in May. I cannot wait to get my first Playbill!

We are seeing:

Something Rotten! (Picked this over Fun Home as it seemed more our style of musical and may have a chance to see Fun Home if it tours up north since it's likely to win the Tony.)

Skylight (Can't pass up an opportunity to see Mr. Nighy, plus the reviews are good)

The King & I (This was the first musical I was in as a kid so I have a soft spot for it. Also, I can't wait to hear Kelli O'Hara perform live since I've been listening to the Bridges of Madison County cast album on repeat for three months)

Gentlemen's Guide to Love and Murder (My decision to see this was based solely on that amazing number at last year's Tony awards! So happy it's still playing.)

I am curious as to whether anyone has a favorite place to hit post show for drinks/food/desert/music? I was thinking about checking out "Don't Tell Mama" - are there any other places like it to experience some classic Broadway music?

Thanks in advance for your thoughts :)

Updated On: 4/13/15 at 12:00 PM