I saw "Brooklyn" in preview and had heard none of the bad reviews before seeing it so I don't feel that I was influenced by anyone.
Yes, the singers are good and yes, the story is pretty bad and some of the lyrics are so trite that you can't believe that a professional actually wrote those words.
I do intend to get the CD. I don't mind putting out the $13.99 that it would cost me to get it from Amazon.com. I will not, however, pay any more than that to sit in a theatre and watch the show again.
The best thing about the show, IMHO, is listening to some of the songs and I can do that from the comfort of my home (or car) and then I can go to the theatre to see something that I feel would actually be worth a trip to the theatre.
"Smart! And into all those exotic mystiques -- The Kama Sutra and Chinese techniques. I hear she knows more than seventy-five. Call me tomorrow if you're still alive!"