You make some great points, jasonf. I've been going there on and off for a very long time, too, and I agree with the quality of the shows - from fabulous to cringing in my seat. Still, their young, non-equity cast/chorus usually does an outstanding job. Talented, enthusiastic and committed to doing their best. It's the "stars" who phone in their performances, too often. I'm looking forward to seeing their modern slate, too. I also agree that the diversity of their program has given me the chance to be exposed to shows I might otherwise have skipped.
New Hope is a great town, but I have to admit, I liked it better when all of those funky, less trendy shops were there. There used to be a neat Moraccan place over by the train station. Gone now. And Meow,Meow. Gone, too, and several others.Opps! Sorry I got off-topic.
"And the postman sighed as he scratched his head, you really rather thought she ought to be dead..."