Well the original got almost everything wrong about Charity. If it were a sparkling new interpretation it would have had a better critical reception. It was a lazy, misguided revival that didn't trust its source material.
Personally i think had they used the Fosse choreography people/reviewers wouldn't have been quite so quick to jump on it. I do agree the choreography for this production was awful.
Sweet Charity really needs a director/choreographer not a director AND a choreographer. The book is too limp for a non-stylistic production to work. I think someone like Susan Stroman or Jerry Mitchell could have easily used their own choreography successfully.
If you saw Cilento's "choreography" you'd be more than happy with Stroman's prop-ography.
And I loved Applegate, for the record. I thought she was charming. She's a good dancer, I saw her earlier into the injury and though tentative, I could tell the talent was there, who happened to be in a awful production.