Well, thank you for posting your reviews. I got to see the show on Saturday. I saw the original cast back in the nineties and while most of you liked it very much with Ruthie's comeback I have to say I was quite disapointed.
Having seen the show with Bonnie Langford in NYC in October I was expecting the same level of fun .....
Roxie : Ruthie was great in the acting department and delivered a great performance. However, she can not dance like she's used to but that is not what bothered me the most. She didn't lift her legs once like she used to, maybe the fact that she put on weight did not help her. Her "Me and My Baby" was nicely danced though. My problem was with her voice. Maybe she was sick but is her voice getting huskier year after year ? When I saw Marguerite in 2008 her voice was very different from the CD. You can barely hear herself in either her belt or lyrical range.
Velma : As Terra hurt herself during the matinee, Vivian Carter was on as Velma. What a great actress. A bit too young compared to Ruthie's Roxie but she really stole the show in my opinion. During "I am my own Bestfriend" we could not hear Ruthie, Vivian has an awesome voice. She might need to work a bit on her comic timing but that's about it.
Mama : Jasna Ivir was ok, a bit too loud at times. She lacked the sexyness of some Mamas I've seen in the past.
Amos : He was great. Just great. And what a voice.
Billy : Boring with a weak voice. He could not sing the end of "We both reached for the gun". Amos could have done it better.
Mary Sunshine : OK
The ensemble : Very young and attractive people with awesome dance skills.
The ensemble on Broadway is much, much older and get the vaudevilesque idea of the piece and that is what I missed with that cast. It is a clean job but does not have the heart the show once had. They sing well, dance well and act well but I do not feel like they are getting what this whole thing is really about.
I had a great time despite my mixed feeling and I hope Terra will get better in the near future.
In my heart, I found the answered dream,
and in my soul I found the song, and in my friends
I found the magic, the love,
the moon up above- they were mine, all mine, all along..!