Um, Stevos... you KNOW the plot to Side Show, right? It's pertinent that Jake is black, due to storyline conflictions. A major storyline is that Jake is in love with Violet, but she can't be with him BECAUSE he's black. Thus, colorblind casting is NOT an option. Jake MUST be black and the twins MUST be white, as must Buddy and Terry or the plot makes absolutely no sense. That's like casting myself as Sarah Brown in Ragtime... sure, I can sing the part and for a little white girl, I got me some soul and am often told I sound like a big black girl, but that doesn't change the fact I white (as much as I WISH it did... God, what I'd ****ing give to be black... seriously, although I guess a downer would be that I couldn't play Daisy...).
Seriously, it's a great role, but you must be black to play Jake. It's much like Ragtime or Dreamgirls in that respect.
"You! You are the worst thing to happen to musical theatre since Andrew Lloyd Webber! And you, well, I just plain don't like you."
~Stewart Gilligan Griffin