#1
Posted: 11/10/09 at 12:37pm
OK so despite some problems I have with the film itself, I'm thankful to have this documentary on DVD and with some great extras, but...
I know it was foolish to even dream this kinda thing
, but I was hoping among the extras they'd include the professionally filmed clips from Chorus Line's original and revived productions--stuff like TV performances, maybe even tv commercials, etc. Most of all though I was hoping to get the wonderful 7 minute opening they did for the 1976 Tony Awards.
Yeah I know we can see this easily online right now, but surely the quality would be much better (despite old video source tape) on DVD. I suspect the reason we didn't get this clip (or the terrific Dreamgirls Tony clip, or even the wonderful Promises Promises Turkey Lurkey Time Tony clip) on any of the Broadway's Lost Treasures DVDs (since Chorus Line is one of the best known Broadway classics ever) is due to the notoriously tight control of the Michael Bennett estate...
But surely including them on this documentary (where the clips are included partially anyway) would be the ideal place? At this point, with them easily viewable in bad quality online for free, why not allow fans to finally get at them? I know often it's a rights issue but didn't the Estate already sign off many of those for the documentary?
Similarly I'm always dismayed when even the two disc editions of recent musical theatre film adaptations have ZERO footage from the original stage version. Chicago, Rent, Dreamgirls, even musicals I'm not so keen on like Mama Mia and Hairspray are all guilty of this at best only including still images (Chicago does have that cool bit with Liza on the Dinah Shore show). In this case I do get that it's probably a licensing/rights issue, the film owners rarely having anything to do with the people who own the original imagery (the Phantom of the Opera 2 disc set does have that great documentary about the stage musical which has many great clips). Still I really feel for any truly "collector's edition" DVD of these adaptations of very famous stage musicals, to not include any of the clips out there really is just a wasted opportunity...
I know it was foolish to even dream this kinda thing
Yeah I know we can see this easily online right now, but surely the quality would be much better (despite old video source tape) on DVD. I suspect the reason we didn't get this clip (or the terrific Dreamgirls Tony clip, or even the wonderful Promises Promises Turkey Lurkey Time Tony clip) on any of the Broadway's Lost Treasures DVDs (since Chorus Line is one of the best known Broadway classics ever) is due to the notoriously tight control of the Michael Bennett estate...
But surely including them on this documentary (where the clips are included partially anyway) would be the ideal place? At this point, with them easily viewable in bad quality online for free, why not allow fans to finally get at them? I know often it's a rights issue but didn't the Estate already sign off many of those for the documentary?
Similarly I'm always dismayed when even the two disc editions of recent musical theatre film adaptations have ZERO footage from the original stage version. Chicago, Rent, Dreamgirls, even musicals I'm not so keen on like Mama Mia and Hairspray are all guilty of this at best only including still images (Chicago does have that cool bit with Liza on the Dinah Shore show). In this case I do get that it's probably a licensing/rights issue, the film owners rarely having anything to do with the people who own the original imagery (the Phantom of the Opera 2 disc set does have that great documentary about the stage musical which has many great clips). Still I really feel for any truly "collector's edition" DVD of these adaptations of very famous stage musicals, to not include any of the clips out there really is just a wasted opportunity...