Thanks for posting this Morosco.
You know, I've been wondering about this whole microphone thing since they mentioned they were going to do the show as it was done in 1975. After they mentioned the sets and the costumes (virtually the same exactly), and the orchestrations and the lighting (only slightly modified, mostly in the name of technology), I thought about the actual sound design next.
I'm thinking of it from a human and also a "realistic" point of view. (Hopefully this will make sense as I write it...)
With floor mics (which were used in the original show), the performers weren't as amplified... but you also got a better sense of the location of the physical sound. You can actually tell that it's coming from down stage left, or up stage right, etc. There is a little more of an organic feel that these voices on stage are coming from the dancers at a (supposedly) “real” audition.
I don't see how this "realness" could possibly come through here if they’re all wearing body mics. It would be so obvious to anyone in the audience that the dancers' voices are artificially amplified, and I think it would add a sense of phoniness to the occasion. It would lessen the stakes, because we would constantly "hear" that it wasn't real.
I’m very sensitive to sound and sound design, and I work on it for my job... So I may be picking up on something that most theatre-goers either wouldn’t notice, or even care about.
But I’m curious if anyone else has thought about that... and its potential impact or affect on this show in particular.
I usually believe that people "feel" sound, and understand that it effects them emotionally, even if they don't or can't pick up on the specifics of what they are hearing.
And I do think it would affect them and their experience sitting in the audience for this production of ACL.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22