As a writer, I find this a very interesting thread.
Here are my candidates:
AS LONG AS HE NEEDS ME (Oliver!)--The song is originally sung by Nancy in Act One as a song of masochistic love for Bill Sykes. She then reprises it in Act Two in reference to Oliver Twist before she decides to return him to Brownlow and meets her untimely and tragic end at the hands of Bill.
SEND IN THE CLOWNS (A Little Night Music)--Sung as a ruefully ironic and bittersweet lament of missed opportunities by Desiree in Act Two, it is reprised as a song of conciliation and self-acceptance by Desiree and Frederick at the end of the show.
IF I LOVED YOU (Carousel)---Billy and Julie express their love in tentative conditionals in Act One. After Billy's death and return to earth, he reprises a half-chorus and confesses his love for her ("HOW I loved you...") from beyond the grave.
LOVE, DON'T TURN AWAY (110 in the Shade)---Lizzie, an old maid, expresses her yearnings for romantic love early on in Act One. Later in the act, she reprises it in counterpoint to the community's prayer for rain, making a mythic connection between Lizzie's and the town's parched desires.
GOODNIGHT, MY SOMEONE/SEVENTY-SIX TROMBONES---Marian Paroo abd Harold Hill respectively sings these songs in Act One. In Act Two, portions of the songs are alternately reprised by the two characters and it becomes evident the songs are the same tune in different arrangements. Psychologically, the audience has been prepared for their eventual union from the very beginning.
THE IMPOSSIBLE DREAM (Man of LA Mancha)---Performed by Quixote/Cervantes in Act One, it is reprised by Aldonza to a disillusioned Quixote on his deathbed in Act Two to reawaken the memory of his quest.
TONIGHT (West Side Story)/MY LOVE (Candide)---In the original productions of both musicals, these songs are reprised as a quintet and quartet, respectively, to thrilling effect.
STORMY WEATHER (Lena Horne: The Lady and Her Music)---Obviously not a musical, this is, however, one of the strongest reprises in a show on record. In her one-woman show, Ms. Horne originally sang this standard as a souvenir of her Cotton Club days. Later, in Act Two, she pulled all the stops out and reprised it as an electrifying testament of survival.
Updated On: 8/9/03 at 12:12 PM