Saw Brooklyn last night. Talent? Yes! The voices were wonderful, including the pit singers. Score? One really good song, others were weak at best. Book? It's a show about a show that has a show in it? Weak at best, although I have enjoyed musicals whose books were weak, this was weaker than most.
Sets were unimpressive, although the props were clever and the costumes were at times quite inventive and humorous.
I hate to be preached to in a musical; present the show and let me take away what I can. Too much moralizing!
Overall, it would have been more appropriate to off Broadway but if you can get a cheap ticket, not a total loss of an evening since there are some fine performances that make it worth seeing.
Live long and prosper.
Marriage equity now!