I love GODSPELL, but I've seen (or participated in) so MANY awful productions--I think it is best when you play yourself putting on the various characters required by the parables. Ideally, the script should be a taking-off place, not taken literally. The cast and director should do a great deal of experimenting and workshopping, coming up with contemporary characters and pop-culture references. That's why it's such a good show for colleges and high schools, who have the freedom to use that approach--it's really a show about the theatrical process itself. The best production I ever saw of GODSPELL did one parable as a Judge Judy episode, one as a "Titanic" takeoff, one as a "Family Feud" show pitting the cast of "Married With Children" against the cast of "The Beverly Hillbillies", etc., etc. Obviously very dated references now, but that's the point--no two productions of this show should ever be quite alike. That's why I hate it when summer-stock theatres trot out GODSPELL as a "can't miss" warhorse, using the same old 1960s flower-child/magical junkyard concept that we're all sick of.
I ask in all honesty/What would life be?/Without a song and a dance, what are we?/So I say "Thank you for the music/For giving it to me."