#1
Posted: 8/7/05 at 11:24am
I was wondering if the "How To Succeed" 1995 revival soundtrack is worth buying?
#2
Posted: 8/7/05 at 11:30am
Loved the show and love the revival cast recording.
" ...the happiness in the tune convinces me that I'm not afraid."
#3
Posted: 8/7/05 at 11:33am
There is no revival soundtrack.
There is the soundtrack to the film, starring Robert Morse and Rudy Valle and Michele Lee;
There is the Original Broadway Cast recording starring Robert Morse and Rudy Valle;
and
There is the Revival Broadway Cast recording starring Matthew Broderick.
Which one are you considering?
There is the soundtrack to the film, starring Robert Morse and Rudy Valle and Michele Lee;
There is the Original Broadway Cast recording starring Robert Morse and Rudy Valle;
and
There is the Revival Broadway Cast recording starring Matthew Broderick.
Which one are you considering?
#4
Posted: 8/7/05 at 11:35am
Calling a Cast Recording (from a live show) a soundtrack is a major faux pas in theatre circles.
Soundtracks are for movies. Cast Recordings are for live theatre.
That being said - I have the 1995 Revival Cast Recording and I find it quite enjoyable.
Soundtracks are for movies. Cast Recordings are for live theatre.
That being said - I have the 1995 Revival Cast Recording and I find it quite enjoyable.
#5
Posted: 8/7/05 at 11:36am
It's a good, solid recording. No substitute for the original cast, though. Still, you may prefer it's sound quality. (Recording has come a long way since the '60s!)
I saw this show when it was on Broadway. Matthew was delightful. Megan Mullally was cute (if a bit too cartoonish for that particular role), and Lillias White stopped the show as the secretary riffing on "The Brotherhood of Man." Unfortunately, I don't think Ms. White did quite as well on this recording as she did live on stage. You had to be there. Seriously, I thought the roof was gonna come down from the applause she got after that song!
I saw this show when it was on Broadway. Matthew was delightful. Megan Mullally was cute (if a bit too cartoonish for that particular role), and Lillias White stopped the show as the secretary riffing on "The Brotherhood of Man." Unfortunately, I don't think Ms. White did quite as well on this recording as she did live on stage. You had to be there. Seriously, I thought the roof was gonna come down from the applause she got after that song!
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22
#6
Posted: 8/7/05 at 11:38am
Get the original - Broderick can't come close to Robert Morsse.
#7
Posted: 8/7/05 at 11:39am
Don't forget Victoria Clark as Smitty. :)
" ...the happiness in the tune convinces me that I'm not afraid."
#8
Posted: 8/7/05 at 12:07pm
I didn't even know that was Victoria Clark! She was great as Smitty. So was Luba Mason as Hedy LaRue. Va-va-voom! And Jonathan (voice of "Jafar") Freeman.
It was a solid revival cast.
It was a solid revival cast.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22
#9
Posted: 8/7/05 at 12:14pm
Jesus. We have too many queens on this board.
Soundtrack, Cast Recording, WHO THE HELL CARES? Just answer the guy's question. You know what they meant.
Soundtrack, Cast Recording, WHO THE HELL CARES? Just answer the guy's question. You know what they meant.
"I know now that theatre saved my life." - Susan Stroman
#11
Posted: 8/7/05 at 12:21pm
You could also answer their question as well as make them aware of an error so that they don't make it again the future.
I know I would want someone to do the same for me. Part of the fun of these boards for me is the learning aspect of it.
I know I would want someone to do the same for me. Part of the fun of these boards for me is the learning aspect of it.
Updated On: 8/7/05 at 12:21 PM
#12
Posted: 8/7/05 at 12:22pm
Albin, I'm just so sick of the soundtrack/cast recording review. People make mistakes. Give them a break. So many people on this board make theater folk seem like total unwelcoming snobs.
"I know now that theatre saved my life." - Susan Stroman
#13
Posted: 8/7/05 at 12:23pm
Well, it does get potentially confusing, as there is a film soundtrack for How to Succeed...though, of course, not from 1995.
"Gif me the cobra jool!"
#14
Posted: 8/7/05 at 12:26pm
Buy the 1995 DVD of the movie. You get the soundtrack and the movie.
#15
Posted: 8/7/05 at 12:38pm
I care. It's a Cast Recording, not a Soundtrack.
Get the Original Broadway Cast Recording. It's the best in my opinion.
Get the Original Broadway Cast Recording. It's the best in my opinion.
#16
Posted: 8/7/05 at 12:57pm
you think this is unwelcoming? try All That Chat. A cast recording is not a sountrack, simple! this is theatre geek 101.
Updated On: 8/7/05 at 12:57 PM
#17
Posted: 8/7/05 at 1:00pm
Why don't we set up a spot in Shubert Alley to flog anyone who calls it a soundtrack.
If you really care about educating someone, a PM will do it. Unless it's more about showing how superior you really are.
If you really care about educating someone, a PM will do it. Unless it's more about showing how superior you really are.
#18
Posted: 8/7/05 at 1:02pm
Oh yeah. Knowing the difference between those two things is a real intellectual achievement! I am soooooo superior!
Updated On: 8/7/05 at 01:02 PM
#19
Posted: 8/7/05 at 1:04pm
Well since this show has both a soundtrack and a cast recording, maybe telling someone the difference is important.
And whether you like it or not, it's a Cast Recording, and you WILL look uneducated if you call it anything different. Period.
Ps: Hot pic Chita33.
And whether you like it or not, it's a Cast Recording, and you WILL look uneducated if you call it anything different. Period.
Ps: Hot pic Chita33.
#20
Posted: 8/7/05 at 1:07pm
What is it with some of you! Knowing is better than not knowing. Why do people get so pissed at being corrected? Suck it up, say thank you and move on.
#21
Posted: 8/7/05 at 1:08pm
If someone called a horse a donkey wouldn't you correct them?
#22
Posted: 8/7/05 at 1:09pm
Normally, I am right there with you on the PM will do it mindset.
However, perhaps there are multiple people reading this thread who are unaware that there is a difference between cast recordings and soundtracks and by posting it in the thread it will help clear that up for several people.
Regardless, it really isn't that big of a deal.
I 2nd what an earlier poster said. I think the OBC Cast Recording is probably a better listen, but the quality and the "polish" isn't anywhere near as good as the 1995 Revival Cast Recording.
Just depends on your tastes I guess. I collect, so I actually have both.
However, perhaps there are multiple people reading this thread who are unaware that there is a difference between cast recordings and soundtracks and by posting it in the thread it will help clear that up for several people.
Regardless, it really isn't that big of a deal.
I 2nd what an earlier poster said. I think the OBC Cast Recording is probably a better listen, but the quality and the "polish" isn't anywhere near as good as the 1995 Revival Cast Recording.
Just depends on your tastes I guess. I collect, so I actually have both.
#23
Posted: 8/7/05 at 1:14pm
My problem with some revivals is that they tend to treat the material as a nostalgia piece, and perform the material a bit tongue in cheek. While a revival may sound better to more modern ears, I think the original recordings of these shows tend to be a bit more "of the moment" and have a lot more excitement to them. MOst were recording right after rave reviews and you can tell that in the performers voices. The original How to Succeed is a great example of this. The remaster is great sounding, and has some fun extras at the end. The are even a few tracks from the Revival on the OBC remaster, including Clark's "How to..." Reprise that was put in instead of the great "Cinderella, Darling".
#24
Posted: 8/7/05 at 1:15pm
Ah, I didn't realize that there was a remaster out there.
I might have to look into getting that one.
I might have to look into getting that one.
Tickets From $59
Tickets From $71
Tickets From $71
Tickets From $95