Eh, depends. Personalities vary. Some of us would just say "all right, then" and move on, and others will stand and argue with an opinion (I'm sure I've probably done both, at one point or another).
Emcee, I remember that whole fiasco, and would like to apologize if you feel I was one of the people who felt you needed to be psychoanalyzed (although I really don't think any of us did... we just get sort of defensive, sometimes). I don't think I've ever seen anyone verbally attack (or attack in any way, for that matter) someone else for disliking (or not being enamoured with) the show, but I could understand why it might come off that way. As I said: we do get defensive sometimes, and will attempt to disqualify someone's opinion (which we shouldn't, but think about what your reaction would be in that situation, if the show was
Sweeney Todd, or something) but I don't think we would ever consider anyone to be less of a person because they didn't like the show. I certainly wouldn't, and I would hope that nobody else would, either.
However, if Humpers (or anyone else) expressed a negative opinion about the show in a manner that was overly rude and/or offensive, it's another matter entirely.
Jeez, I never realized what a bad reputation we've made for ourselves...