I know at least a dozen straight guys (including myself) who LOVE musicals. There's nothing hard to believe about that. If I had the income to have half the stuff he has in his apartment, I'd probably be the same. I'd definitely have pictures, CDs, posters, and Playbills.
The best is just finding a girlfriend who loves musicals as much as you do. Which I did. Helps finance some of those pricey tickets :)
Shows Seen - Swing!**, Rent (Broadway)**, The Lion King***, Wicked*****, Legally Blonde***, Chicago****, Cats***, Fiddler on the Roof***, Burn the Floor**, In the Heights***, Hair*****, A Christmas Story**, Rock of Ages***, Vanities*, Billy Elliot****, Next to Normal*****, 9 to 5**, Mary Poppins***, Guys and Dolls***, Aladdin***, Les Miserables*****
Upcoming Shows - Cinderella, Oklahoma!, Damn Yankees, Rent
Paramount Theater and 5th Avenue Theater season ticket holder
Proud Gleek