Oh gosh, I hope not. I just saw Tim today at a matinee of Rent, and I HATED him. Not him, of course, but his acting and screaming and yelling and singing and I'm-angry-so-I'm-gonna-attack-Mimi attitude. It was my friend's first time seeing the show after having seen the movie and loving it, and he agreed that Tim was horrible as Roger. Blah. Full review soon. :)
I am so happy he extended. My dream cast would be to see Chris Hanke, Tim Howar, and Karmine onstage together with the current ensemble. I was satisfied after seeing it Wednesday and plan on going back again soon to lotto when Matt leaves.
Lets hope so. While he may not be everyones cup of tea he is easily my favorite Roger and I can't really explain why but the anger in him just really worked for me
RIP Natasha Richardson. ~You were a light on this earth ~
Same here gustof. I saw Cary twice and he played by the same typical formulas I felt. I mean I had no complaints, but I felt like that approach was nothing new and idk I didn't really feel it much. I saw Jay Wilikison twice as well and he was great. He was a more reluctant Roger and played the part realistically and had a great voice. Tim had the best act 2 Roger I ever saw and all the emotion was well invested in the right parts. His voice wasn't anything perfect, but his acting was terrific and combined to make a character I entirely was able to understand.
The least angry Roger I've ever seen was Adam Pascal...only in the movie unfortunately.
And I adored Tim. Yes he was angry, but he had a fantastic tender side to Roger that I never really saw in Will Chase or Cary. I agree completely with C is for Company.
exactly...I really wish I could formulate what it is about Tim's performance that I just find so endearing. I think maybe the fact that he isn't the crazy good singer that some of the other Rogers have been makes it all the more fascinating. I sort of thought that his voice was a different kind of "rock" voice but still very rock. I found his "What You Own" to be one of the best I've ever seen (minus the fact that he was paired up w/ Caplan who just looked bored and arrogant) there was just so much pain in his performance. You could just see it through his rage. Ahhh I love it!
RIP Natasha Richardson. ~You were a light on this earth ~
As I said earlier, I've never seen Adam play Roger on stage back "in the day", but I did see him at Rent 10. Of course, every cast member was top-notch then, it being a special performance, but he blew me away there, and still wasn't as angry as every other Roger I've seen. What he did then and on film definitely worked.
Anyway, back on track. It seems somtime that he can't control how powerful his voice is. He puts every bit of himself into songs, which of course makes for a fantastic performance, but sometimes it's a bit too much. Like when he completely drowned Gordon out in Will I, for example.
Ah, Caplan. Yet another reason I'm glad Tim is staying longer. I can't wait to see him perform alongside a Mark who CARES. Especially in "What You Own" and "Goodbye Love", where Tim really shines.
Ah, Matt always looks bored and arrogant. Except in stagedoor picture, where he looks like a chipmunk on speed.
I know you have to be careful about drowning out Gordon as it's the wonderful Luther Creek who has a voice worth hearing! haha oh Monica that was hilarious and also very true :)
RIP Natasha Richardson. ~You were a light on this earth ~
"Except in stagedoor picture, where he looks like a chipmunk on speed."
OMG, you're right!
"You never really understand a person until you consider things from his point of view - until you climb into his skin and walk around in it."
To Kill A Mockingbird
I've heard (not through reliable sources, but it's definitely quite a prolific rumor) that Tim is leaving to tour with his band but will be returning to Rent. The speculation is that since they just hired Christopher J. Hanke, and we've yet to hear any casting news for Roger, a swing will be bumped up to play Roger until Tim's return.
From what I remember, he does not look the part really at all. Um, I'm sure he is talented and could prove me wrong with that, but I really hope Tim stays, I want to see a good leading trio when I go back to lotto in August.
I really liked Tim as Roger. They seem to be cutting it a bit close on announcing whether he's staying or leaving. In broadway.com's announcment of Christopher as Mark, they definitely made it sound as though Tim had extended.
Although I don't particularly dislike Tim's Roger, it's unfortunate that with someone like Luther on the stage every night, that HE isn't playing Roger.
Hmmm. Tim's got a MySpace bulletin posted that says, among other things:
Also, message or comment if you are planning on attending the July 29th show! (Tim's last scheduled performance!) We need the info... details why later!
Perhaps I'll message whoever runs the page and ask what the deal is, exactly, if he's not contractually obligated to keep his mouth shut.