Just bought the Aida soundtrack...luvin adam in it how bout you? — Page 2

I enjoy Sherie (and Lisa)'s performance as well as the staging in that song, but I don't find it to be a stand-out, IMO. It really depends on the Amneris, whereas the three songs that I listed give me chills no matter who's playing Aida. (Yes, including Toni. Barely.)

---

Tiff - I actually do just like the song itself - even Donny Osmond did a fairly decent version of it - that has to say SOMETHING for it's viability!

Simone is an old friend of mine, so her God Loves Nubia is my favorite (I know, SACRILEGE!) I'm very happy I have her performance of it on the Today Show on tape

Updated On: 2/18/05 at 01:31 AM

I concur, Emcee. I've heard clips of her and I like what I heard though.

DGrant, is Donny the one who sings on the concept album? I listened to parts of the concept album once and never again.

---

MY *OPINIONS*
BORING SONGS: Elaborate Lives, The Gods Love Nubia, Written In The Stars (I know, I know, so many of you love them but not me)
EXTRAORDINARY SONGS: Easy as Life (so powerful, can't believe others haven't mentioned it), I Know the Truth (maybe the most powerful in the show), Every Story is a Love Story, My Strongest Suit (I just realized that it's mostly the Amneris songs I love)
GOOD BUT NOT MY FAVORITES: A Step Too Far, Not Me, Enchantment Passing Through

Am I the only one who actually liked the Zoser songs? I always felt they kicked ass live on stage. I agree they sound a bit too 'pop-ish' on the OCR but live they were great.

DGrant, you keep spreading the word about Patrick But I love the 'scratchy clawing at the notes'.

QM

---

Wow, I love Heathers voice.

I think all the songs worked for me except Zosers songs, yet I liked Radames part in Like Father, mostly because it showed Adam's more "rock" side in this part - but thats just when he's singing it :).

I for one LOVE I Know the Truth and Every Story. Strongest Suit is fun to watch not my *favorite* Amneris song.

---

I actually don't really like the music, but some of the songs are good. However most of them either bore me or make me cringe. And yeah, John Hickok is really good, so I feel badly that he got awful songs. I got to see him in Little Women and meet him and he made fun of me! Sorry, random moment.

I LOVE Aida! I wish I'd seen it more than once when it was in NYC (especially since I saw the first half of the show in front row rush seats - terrible). Thank goodness the tour coincides w/ my trip to KC! Anyone know how the touring cast is?

Does this mean that everything is going to be completely different? Choreography, sets, etc?

QM - musically, the Zoser songs aren't the strongest in the show, but I definitely agree that they were fun on stage. The choreography was a little weird, but it was fun to watch... with all of the colored lighting and such, too.

To all of you who are saying his songs are "awful" I think you need to realize that they're songs written to tell you something about the character, not necessarily to be mind-blowingly good. AND, it's a pretty flat character at that. The same goes for Fortune, I think. That was really written because the creative team needed some way to introduce Radames through a song - that song went through several stages of metamorphosis before it even semi-worked, as did they character. Originally, Radames was essentially cardboard - you saw no emotions, no motivation - he was just like a puppy in love with a beautiful woman.
... just a point on interest when you're judging these songs, I think. A lot of them are more character-driven than they are musically driven, which hurts the musical/lyrical aspect of them.

mirramar - the sets and costumes are different on this new tour. It's not really the Disney production, physically. The music and book sound like they're similar, with a couple of changes. For example, Aida's singing what on Broadway was Radames' Letter, and originally was sung by Amneris. It's really the owner-less letter, I suppose.

MFL.... why did he make fun of you? I hope he was just playing around! I've always found him to be very nice.

---

Well done, QM. I thought it was Pascohl, though?

Matthius, trust me. There's quite a large camp of people who dislike him.

---

No prob. I'm on the fence about whether to see it or not if it comes to somewhere within decent driving distance of NYC.

---

wooo, campy captain! I bet he loved it. :-P

... Pascle?

---

Updated On: 2/18/05 at 11:13 AM