It did win Best Musical and Best Score, but that was an especially weak season for new musicals--the only other musical with an original score that year was The Addams Family. My favorite musicals of that season were actually Everyday Rapture and Sondheim on Sondheim, and neither of them were really musicals in the traditional sense (one was a cabaret and one was a revue). It was not Broadway's finest season. Actually, I thought American Idiot was the artistic triumph of the season. Saw it three times and honestly, the most recent non-equity touring cast was the best I'd seen.
A 400 seat theatre in Oklahoma is not going to produce as quality of work as a 199 seat theatre in New York. I would say that you can usually rely on some quality of work in New York, but anywhere else you have to try every theatre company out to see which ones are good. Oof! So wrong. So so so so WRONG. Unless by "some quality of work" you mean to include the bad quality as well as the good. Being a theatre in New York is no guarantee of any quality whatsoever. Ask anyone who has seen numerous shows, both on and off Broadway. Or just simply read reviews. Better yet, go check out the long-running hit play, Perfect Crime, and let us know about the "quality". Someday I'll regale you with my story attending the "Off-Broadway Return of The Fantasticks" (not the official revival that's currently running. It was indeed off-Broadway on Restaurant Row and was devoid of quality as well as talent. Being a theatre company in New York did not automatically rate their quality higher than a Texas elementary school production.
There are also transfers of regional productions to Broadway that are drastically changed for Broadway, yet somehow end up being worse than the original regional production. Jekyll & Hyde and Don't Dress For Dinner immediately come to mind. for J&H, it was the production values, but for Don't Dress for Dinner, it was the fatal change in cast.
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian
Updated On: 9/15/14 at 02:42 PM