Is it any worse than the school version of Les Mis? Like any 17 year olds should ever be singing Valjean! (No offense to anyone who's ever done the school version, I have just always thought it was a horrid idea.)
I also want to go on record as saying I hope the rights for Rent NEVER get released for community theatres to do. Anyone who's done community theatre knows why....Do you really want to hear the high school choir teacher playing Maureen? Or the eight billion teenage girls who will come to auditions with Rodgers and Hammerstein songs? Yikes! And, when there is a shortage of guys (happens a lot) having Angel played by a girl? I've done a ton of community theatre, and the idea of doing shows like Miss Saigon, Les Mis, and Rent is a nightmare.
Sorry if this post offends anyone, but come on!
There's always room for pathos - and jazz hands.