The Sound of Music and The Phantom of the Opera. I like most of them, but those are my favorites.
Kay: You might want to be careful about wearing that. Steven doesn't like things that are quite so obvious.
Crystal: When Steven doesn't like what I wear, I take it off!
-The Opposite Sex
The Sound of Music by far, most of the reasons being sentimental. Second would be Phantom though I agree that Chicago is much better on film than in person.
Bye Bye Birdie My Fair Lady Cinderella The Producers (everyone has they're own opinion about what they want from a movie musical. Me, I don't mind a literal filming of the stage show. You risk losing the spirit of the musical if you change too much.)
As awful as it may sound, THE FANTASTICKS, but with the deleted scenes put back in. A friend of mine who knows how to do such things re-edited the DVD with them back, and the film actually works far better. And just conceptually, it was a pretty interesting attempt at an almost unfilmable musical.
Thank Heaven several million people do not share such a sentiment.
Why? What difference would it make if everyone hated it? Wouldn't you still like them just as much? My enjoyment of films has nothing to do with what other people like.