Now from A Little Night Music and Little Shop of Horrors
Though I guess it's a little obvious, A New Deal For Christmas in both Annie and Annie Warbucks -- though that's the same song...
Is there a title song to "Amour"? There's an Amor in Nine....
"Look at Me" -- Violet and Witches of Eastwick
"Another Day" in Rent and Tap Dance Kid
Cy Coleman wrote an "Atlantic City" song, but I don't know if it's in any musicals -- and there's Atlantic City in Ragtime. And the Springsteen song...
"Love Makes the World Go Round" from Me and My Girl and Carnival
"Love Song" from Pippin and Celebration
"More" in LaChiusa's Wild Party and -- if we're making it theater - Putting It Together
Again, not QUITE theater, but "Santa Fe" from Rent and Newsies...
I'm starting to diverge a bit here...
I always thought Mel Brooks should totally have written a song called "Four Jews in a Room Bitching"