Echoing IrisTinkerbell on a lot of this but...
I would probably avoid The Crucible, as it fits none of your criteria.
She Loves Me - it's a romantic musical comedy, if you don't get HipTix, there's a discount for $50 in the mid mezz /rear mezz. Buy @ box office to avoid online fees. See if she knows Zachary Levi or Jane Krawkowski and might be a fan of either of them.
The King and I - though not a comedy, it's a classic in an absolutely gorgeous production, get $32 advanced tix online through Lincoln Center's Linctix (subscription is free). I feel like this show is very quintessential Broadway
Fully Committed - hilarious one-man play, easy rush if you're willing to wait the day of - $40 tix - and/or try the lottery ($30). Easy choice if either of you are Modern Family fans. I'm not but I loved Jesse Tyler Ferguson's performance
School of Rock - musical comedy, really upbeat, not sure if you know anything about the movie, but it's a good measure to whether you'll enjoy this
Something Rotten - musical comedy that's both fun and funny, and has some cute romantic elements if that matters. As long as either of you enjoy clever wordplay and know some Shakespeare stuff (from school, etc.), since it parodies Shakespeare, then you're fine
Kinky Boots - musical comedy, might be enjoyable as well, and though I wasn't a fan myself, the last number was great
Updated On: 5/31/16 at 01:58 PM