To me, the show was just dead in the water. There were plenty of directorial choices being made, but none of them seemed to come together.
First, the show was just too damn long. The first act worked for me, despite the length, but it meant that going into the second act, I really had to work to try to care about what was happening.
The staging really didn't seem to fit the space they had to work with. The central "bed" was interesting, but didn't seem to accomplish anything, and was too small to make much of an impact. The people in chairs on stage when they made "exits" could have worked if they'd kept to it, but why only do that some of the time and use actual exits for the rest?
The actors all seemed to have talent, but they weren't really directed. PSH made an impression as Iago, but it seemed like he decided, "This is how I'm playing Iago, the hell with the play the rest of you seem to be in." Also, the shouting was just too much. He was much more effective in his quieter, more sinister scenes with Roderigo. John Ortiz somewhat pulled off the descent into jealousy, but I definitely didn't buy him as a great general, or even as a military man at all. The Duke was the only one in the play who even seemed remotely... militant, I guess?
The women fared a little better. Desdemona was sort of a walking blank in the first act, but she came more into her own in the second act. (And what's with the Michelle Obama dress? I understand it's supposed to be ~modern, but what possible connection is there with Desdemona and the First Lady, especially when the program notes mention that parallels were supposed to be drawn between the Duke and Obama?) The actress who played Emelia came off strongest of the whole bunch, whether because she was directed better or because she just connected to her character more. Her speech towards the end about women's place in the world was the strongest part of the entire play.
Overall, some interesting ideas and talented people, but in the end it just seemed like Peter Sellars just threw everything at the wall and used what stuck.
"Why, I make more money than... than... than Calvin Coolidge! PUT TOGETHER!"
~Lina Lamont
My name wasn't, isn't, and will never be Scott.